Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Charles Koch’s Metaphysics of Business
Charles Koch’s Metaphysics of Business
Apr 21, 2026 10:16 AM

We e guest writer Stephen Schmalhofer to the PowerBlog with this review of Good Profit: How Creating Value for Others Built One of the World’s Most Successful Companies by Charles Koch (Crown Business, 2015). Schmalhofer writes from New York City, where he works in technology and venture capital. He is a graduate of Yale University.

Charles Koch’s Metaphysics of Business

By Stephen Schmalhofer

Adam Smith, that venerable a supporter of free enterprise, held businessmen in low regard, alleging that their every meeting “ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices.” While deference is due to the Scottish master’s lasting insights into the sources of the values of men in The Theory of Moral Sentiments and their success in The Wealth of Nations, I observe that many executives tout their “core values” but not all of panies are successful. Businessman and philanthropist Charles Koch is successful by any financial measure and his unique approach to the creation of value and values at Koch Industries in Wichita, Kansas, where he is chief executive officer, positions him against Smith’s caricature of scheming backroom businessmen.

Charles Koch

Since 1967, Koch has overseen operations at Koch Industries where he developed and implemented “Market-Based Management.” Following a large acquisition by Koch Industries in 2004, he urgently systematized the method and continues to share it with the fervor of an evangelist. Koch’s first book on the method was grandiosely titled The Science of Success: How Market Based Management Built the World’s Largest Private Company but in 2015 he re-entered the marketplace of ideas with a more accessible version — Good Profit: How Creating Value for Others Built One of the World’s Most Successful Companies.

Removing the pretense of science from the title better reflects the method’s foundation in the ideas of spontaneous order and the price system articulated by Austrian economist F.A. Hayek rather than in the pseudo-scientific central planning opposed by the Nobel laureate. Koch Industries’ business model is based on panies that either enhance, or can be improved by, the performance of existing Koch business units. Koch managers seek to integrate these new acquisitions into pany’s operations to realize the expected gains from economies of scale and knowledge sharing. But this integration can blunt the information signals provided by external networks as well as create wasteful internal political battles, especially over budgets and other signs of corporate status unrelated to “good profit.”

To reduce the sclerotic effects of bureaucracy, Koch reintroduces internal market practices. For example, when one Koch businesses purchases products from another Koch business, the transactions are done at prevailing market prices, not with a “family discount.” Internal support services such as accounting or pete alongside external service providers to earn the right to serve each Koch business. This is done not to spark a destructive Hobbesian “war of all against all” but to ensure good stewardship of economic resources (opportunity cost) but also to avoid wasting human talent and creativity (comparative advantage).

Koch’s book is more business philosophy than process, a style shared by entrepreneur and venture capitalist Peter Thiel’s recent reflections on innovation in Zero to One: Notes on Startups, or How to Invent the Future. Both books bring to life the observation of Binx Bollings in Walker Percy’s The Moviegoer that “businessmen are our only metaphysicians.” The end to which Koch orders the actions of pany of more than 100,000 people is to earn “good profit” by striving “to be the counter-party of choice to our customers, munities, and employees.” Striving for this end requires the constant discernment of what your customers value and for how much. To discern and ideally anticipate what your customers need requires a set of personal values to guide decision making within the organization. In Market-Based Management, the cardinal “guiding principle” is integrity.

Too often, integrity is offered up like just another generic corporate value, but trust and reputation are at the heart mercial life. When a business like online retailer Amazon operates with integrity and a mitment to all of its customers, enormous opportunities are created. Netflix, the popular video streaming service, is a significant business customer of Amazon Web Services, the puting platform powering the merce giant and available as a service to startups and Fortune 500 corporations alike. Netflix chooses to use AWS peting directly in the market with Amazon Instant Video’s streaming service. AWS is a technical and business achievement (Revenue: $2 billion Q3-2015) that would not be possible without earning the trust of peer businesses.

The rise of highly-valued and popular two-sided network or marketplace businesses may signal that economist Ronald Coase is due for a revival. The Nobel laureate’s 1937 article answered an ambitious question: Why do firms exist? His simple but powerfully developed response was that transaction costs are not zero and are not ignored by entrepreneurs. Traditionally entrepreneurs respond to these costs with vertical integration and other supersessions of the price system. At Koch, the formation of employees and selection of partners and customers with integrity is emphasized, partly due to the human duty of moral action but also because of the saved “time and money spent on controls, contracts, litigation, and security.”

The internet has helped entrepreneurs slim down the scope of their firms, instead facilitating peer to peer connections (e.g. dating apps) merce (e.g. Etsy, Thumbtack). The speed munication has aided growth but the most successful marketplace businesses have developed ways of signaling the reputation and integrity of buyers and sellers. After an Uber ride, the driver and passenger both rate each other with consequences for their future access to the network and service. Similarly, AirBNB and other vacation property rental marketplaces encourage the host and guest to both provide feedback on their stay. New businesses are providing transparency and aggregating reputation so customers and producers can make better decisions (e.g. TripAdvisor, Yelp, Angie’s List). This is both transactional (Where should I stay on my trip?) but also character forming (How can our team better serve others?). Third parties are also building on top of this reputational ecosystem. For example, the lender OnDeck Capital has incorporated Yelp reviews and similar data when underwriting loans for small businesses.

Good Profit only briefly notes Charles Koch’s political activities. While the political press focuses on his electoral gamesmanship, Koch spends a significant amount of his philanthropic time and money supporting research and education to enhance the public’s understanding of the integrity of free enterprise. A loss of confidence in free enterprise emerges from the growth of “crony capitalism” as a Legatum Institute survey reports that 65 percent of Americans believe most big businesses have dodged taxes, polluted, or bought favors. In other words, a majority of American believe the large corporations lack integrity. For his part, Charles Koch has advocated (in the Wall Street Journal and elsewhere) for an end to government subsidies and protectionism favoring some industries, producers, and consumers over others. Returning once more to the creation of value and values, Koch predicts that with the end of corporate welfare and restoration of integrity in enterprise “[o]ur economy will rebound. Our liberties will be restored.”

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Acton Commentary: Calvin Coolidge and the foundational truths of government
In this mentary, I take a look at Calvin Coolidge and his views on government. Coolidge is important today for many reasons. Chiefly, he’s a striking contrast to our current culture of government and the bloated state. Coolidge was sandwiched in between the progressive era and the rise of the New Dealers. And in his era of leadership, tyrannical leaders who preached the supremacy of the state rose to power abroad. Joseph Stalin and Benito Mussolini in Italy are two...
Rev. Sirico to speak at Freedom of Religion Rally in Grand Rapids, Mich.
A ‘Stand Up For Religious Freedom’ Rally, organized by a coalition of religious, non-profit, pro-life and pro-family organizations and individuals is scheduled for Friday, June 8, at Rosa Parks Circle in Grand Rapids, Mich. The Rev. Robert Sirico is a featured speaker. This public event, scheduled for 10:30 a.m. – 2:30 p.m. EST, is described as “…a peaceful protest to stand up for our religious beliefs and our 1st Amendment Freedoms guaranteed by the US Constitution.” Other speakers include former...
Only a Sunday Believer?
“I do my religion on Sundays.” That was House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi’s answer to a press conference question on the Catholic Church’s stance on contraception, according to The Washington Examiner. Pelosi has consistently backed the Obama administration’s call to force employers to offer abortion, sterilization and birth control as part of employee health care, despite many organizations’ ethical, moral and religious objections (Acton’s PowerBlog offers more here on this topic.) Pelosi’s answer is telling: Her faith should not affect...
Crony Capitalism and Congressional Connections
“It’s helpful to look at the track record of this bipartisan idea that government is smarter and better at picking winners and losers in the marketplace,” said House Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan at a recent hearing on efforts bat cronyism and promote upward mobility. “What we have learned from this bipartisan approach is that corruption does occur, cronyism does occur, and what ends up happening is those who are connected, those who have established connections, those who know the...
On Call Check In Team
The team is growing as I write this. People from the On Call in Culture Community have taken the challenge to begin checking in with how they are being On Call in Culture on an everyday basis. You too can be a part of the encouraging and motivating exercise of checking in. By letting others know what God is doing through you and your work, you can encourage others, stay focused and be more aware of how God is working...
Politics and Pulpits Don’t Mix
Over at Commentary Magazine, Jonathan S. Tobin remarks on the double standards liberals have about allowing politicians to promote political positions from the pulpits of churches and synagogues: [A]llowing a religious event to e the venue for partisan politics is always asking for trouble. No one is saying, or ought to say, that synagogue buildings can’t be used for debates or forums in which politics is discussed. But there is a big difference between a Sunday morning bagel breakfast to...
30 Years Ago Today: Reagan’s Westminster Address
The Washington Post’s editorial page reminds us that today is the 30th anniversary of Ronald Reagan’s address at Westminster Hall, London. The speech, famous for its “ash heap of history line,” was Reagan’s challenge to the Soviet Union’s very legitimacy and pointed to its hollow core. Reagan’s great strength was not just America’s military posture against the Soviets, but that he truly made the Cold War a battle of moral ideas. It was a decisive pivot away from America’s policy...
Being a Christian CEO Means Never Having to Fire Someone
Does being a Christian in business mean you’ll never have to fire someone? Of course not. But that’s one of the many subtexts that is detectable in the recent attention being given to this story: “CEO of Christian Publishing Firm Fires 25 Employees after Anonymous Email.” Now I don’t know any more details than what is contained in the Romenesko report, and it may well be that CEO Ryan Tate acted in an imprudent and incorrect fashion following his receipt...
The Dangers of Democratic Tyranny
In the context mentary on protests like those in Quebec and the Occupy movement more broadly, it’s worth reflecting on the dangers of democratic tyranny. The “people” can be tyrannical just as an individual sovereign or an oligarchy might. That’s why Aristotle considered democracy a defective form of government, because it too easily enshrines the will of the majority into an insuperable law. As Lord Acton put it, “It is bad to be oppressed by a minority, but it is...
Buying a House Makes People Less Entrepreneurial
Suzy Khimm points out an interesting study from the UK’s Spatial Economics Research Centre: Our fixed-effects estimates show that purchasing a house reduces the likelihood of starting a business by 20-25%. … This result is driven by homeowners with mortgages and persists for several years after entering homeownership. … We argue that this finding can be rationalized by the fact that homeowners typically have to overinvest in housing (Brueckner, 1997; Flavin and Yamashita, 2002) and therefore cannot adequately diversify their...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved