Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Capitalism, cronyism, and socialism
Capitalism, cronyism, and socialism
Dec 29, 2025 9:13 PM

“Having a heart for the poor isn’t hard. Having a mind for the poor…that’s the challenge.” –Poverty, Inc.

This quote from the documentary Poverty, Inc. highlights the reason why so many people are willing to give their money to foreign aid, without necessarily understanding its harmful effects. This quote can also shed some light on the recent embrace of socialism by many millennials.

When young people look at the rate of poverty in the U.S. and see that we are not doing as well as some other developed countries, it is easy for them to place this blame on what they believe is “capitalism.” If capitalism has caused the U.S. to experience this poverty then it logically follows that people today, especially millennials, would embrace socialism instead of capitalism.

Given that I am a millennial myself, this makes sense to me. It’s clear that we care about these causes and that we are willing to give our time and money. That’s the easy part. We have a heart for the poor. The challenge is having a mind for the poor.

Having a mind for the poor may seem like a challenge, but it’s certainly not impossible. It all begins with a basic understanding of economics. It is not capitalism that makes people poor, but the crony capitalism that creates a two-tiered society. Socialism does not help the poor, but bination of moral principles and free-market capitalism does. Sam Gregg recently highlightedhow free-markets revived West Germany’s stagnant socialist economy in 1948.

Up until recent political movements, this was rarely debated among the different sides of the political spectrum, especially among the major political parties. Many understood that the power of the free-market was the leading tool used in alleviating poverty.

Economics does not change because of current political and social movements. All that changes is the way that people understand economics. What was once understood as free-market capitalism became horribly mistaken for a big government that chooses winners and losers in the economy. Crony capitalism and free-market capitalism are now grouped together as simply “capitalism” and capitalism has e public enemy number one for millennials and other “social justice warriors.”

Last January, the hashtag #resistcapitalism trended throughout the world on Twitter. Do the people who belong to this movement truly understand what capitalism is?

Socialist/Communist/Anti-capitalist history is heroic! A fight for humanity and for this planet! #ResistCapitalism /KGnEyLScGK

— TayGo (@taygogo) January 8, 2016

This tweet using the hashtag #resistcaptialism, claims that “Socialist/Communist/Anti-capitalist history is heroic!” I can’t think of one situation when socialism munism was “heroic.”

There is something genuinely appealing about belonging to a movement that claims to be for the underdog and against the establishment. It’s appealing to belong to the camp that claims to care for the less fortunate and is actually talking about these issues. This is why a previously unknown senator from Vermont was able to start a movement that quickly attracted millions of followers. Everything about his “democratic socialism” sounds good but none of it makes any economic sense at all.

When college students are asked what they like about Bernie Sanders, one student replies with “I like socialism!” I wonder if she truly knows what socialism is. Or does she know of all the harm that socialism has caused? One phrase that I often hear from millennials is “I don’t know the economics of socialism, but look, it’s working in all of the Nordic countries.”

How can people who know practically nothing about economics and claim to want to help the poor be so quick to embrace an economic system that is responsible for the death of millions of people?

Murray Rothbard once said, “It is no crime to be ignorant of economics… but it is totally irresponsible to have a loud vociferous opinion on economic subjects while remaining in this state of ignorance.”

We cannot let the ignorance of economics blind us to the most effective ways of bringing about poverty alleviation. Instead, we should use what we know about economics to approach the issue of poverty in a way that has proven to be successful. Before we can begin to talk about helping the poor, not only in our country but all across the world, we need to educate ourselves on the differences between capitalism, cronyism, and socialism. We need to educate ourselves on what works and what doesn’t.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The ‘dead-end job’ that has delivered dozens from homelessness
She set out to make a product to help the homeless endure life on the streets during Detroit’s brutal winters. She ended up starting a business that has taken dozens of homeless people from desperation to independence. Veronika Scott grew up in poverty. Her parents’ addictions sometimes plunged their entire family into homelessness, and she remembers being written off as hopeless. “People just looked at you as if you’re worthless by extension, as if you’re doomed to repeat the same...
Conscience for life in fiction, Newman, and Acton
I’m just about halfway through my third reading of Umberto Eco’s marvelous first novel The Name of the Rose. Every time I return to it I find something new. It is a murder mystery set in a medieval monastery but it is also so much more. It is a novel of deceit, desire, philosophy, signs, church, state, religion, heresy, power, powerlessness, truth, error, and the difficulties in discerning them in the world. Some of its greatest conflicts are those of...
‘Unternehmergeist’: The enterprising spirit of East Berlin escape artists
All those who heroically “beat the Wall” were creative and gutsy characters. Their souls were filled with daring cunning and ingenious creativity. They embodied the very enterprising spirit – unternehmergeist – typical of entrepreneurial market-based societies in the West. Read More… Without warning, in the middle of a pleasantly warm August 13 night in 1961, German Democratic Republic authorities hatched and executed their stealthy plan: 10,000 soldiers were ordered to race to secure the border between East and West Berlin...
Stranger Things on America: ‘It’s not rigged!’
My colleague Dylan Pahman posted a worthwhile reflection on the contrast munism and free markets in the Cold War-era setting of Stranger Things. I had his analysis in mind while watching the conclusion of the show’s third season, and in ep. 7 (“The Bite”) there’s a noteworthy exchange between Alexei, the Russian scientist, and Murray Bauman, the Russian-speaking American conspiracy theorist. The two visit the Hawkins fair, which presents an entirely new world to Alexei. Alexei is under the impression...
Turning African game poachers into conservationists
In a new video from theProperty and Environment Research Center in Bozeman, Montana, African hunting guide Mark Haldane explains how “habitat conservation depends on making wildlife petitive with other land uses.” This story is set in the Coutada 11 region in Mozambique along the Zambezi River delta. As PERC explains it, “bymaking the conservation of wildlife habitat economically viable, generating revenue used to fund anti-poaching efforts, and establishing critical e for munities, trophy hunting has proven to be an essential...
5 facts about the Berlin Wall
This weekend, the world celebrates the 30th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall. On November 9, 1989, East Germans began picking at the wall with hammers, picks – even their bare hands – until the mammoth structure that had divided the city for the past 28 years lay in ruins. Here are five facts you need to know about the Berlin Wall. 1. The Berlin Wall grew out of a settlement made at the end of World War...
Toward an economics of abundance: How the cross triumphs over scarcity
For many, economics is ultimately about solving the problem of scarcity—determining how to best use and distribute limited resources. Yet, as some economists are beginning to understand, human creativity and innovation are increasingly allowing us to triumph over such scarcity. As Christians, it’s a tension that’s all too familiar, from creation (abundance) to the fall (scarcity) to the resurrection (abundance) to the here and now (+ not yet). plicated. In a new short film from The Bible Project, we get...
Ronald Reagan statue unveiled on ruins of the Berlin Wall
In the early church, new converts would often raze pagan temples and build Christian churches on the ruins. A secular version of this triumphant gesture took place this weekend as the unveiling of a statue of President Ronald Reagan, and an invocation of God, took place on the toppled remains of the Berlin Wall. “We stand on a piece of real estate that was part of the kill zone,” said Secretary of State Mike Pompeo at the statue’s unveiling. “It...
A Cardinal against Maduro
It is no great secret that one of the few institutions that has stood firm against the socialist Maduro dictatorship in Venezuela is the Catholic Church. Most other institutions have dissolved, broken or promised. The bishops of the Church in Venezuela, however, has been unsparing in their critique of the regime and how it has destroyed the economy and undermined any semblance of constitutional order. This week, however, the Archbishop emeritus of Caracas, Cardinal Jorge Urosa upped the stakes in...
‘Inclusive capitalism’? Why not simply ‘capitalism’
When the feel-good word “inclusive” is applied to the not always feel-good word “capitalism,” it’s a little like mixing oil and water for lovers of socialism. They assume that capitalism is a naturally selfish “look out for your own short term gain while everyone else loses” economic system. Read More… I like the word inclusive. Who doesn’t? My colleague certainly likes the word inclusive, especially when I include more money in her paycheck. My wife likes the word inclusive, when...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved