Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Business Without Religious Liberty: Where Profit Is King
Business Without Religious Liberty: Where Profit Is King
Dec 3, 2025 4:09 AM

The Obama administration and several courts have effectively said that religious freedomdoesn’t apply to money-makers — at least, not when es to purchasing abortion-inducing drugs for your employees.

In a recent piece for USA Today, Mark Rienzi, author of a marvelous paper on the relationship between profit-making and religious liberty, argues that drawing the line on “for-profit” vs. “non-profit” is a mistake for anyone who believes “conscience” belongs in business.

Offering a brief summary of the more recent demonstrations of “conscience” among money-makers, Rienzi invites us to imagine a world where values and business are separated:

We regularly encounter businesses making decisions of conscience. Chipotle recently decided not to sponsor a Boy Scout event because pany disagreed with the Scouts’ policy on openly gay scoutmasters. It was “the right thing to do,” Chipotle said.

Starbucks has ethical standards for the coffee beans it buys. Vegan stores refuse to sell animal products because they believe doing so is immoral. Some businesses refuse to invest in sweatshops or panies or polluters.

You can agree or disagree with the decisions of these businesses, but they are manifestly acts of conscience, both for panies and the people who operate them. Our society is better because people and organizations remain free to have other values while earning a living. Does anyone really want a society filled with organizations that can only focus on profits and are barred from thinking of the greater good?

Yet the persecution we see is quite selective. Starbucks and Chipotle aren’t under scrutiny (yet), so what gives?

For many, their conscience is informed by religious views about activities they can or cannot participate in. Some Jewish store owners cannot sell leavened bread at certain times of the year. Some Muslim truck drivers cannot transport alcohol. Some Catholic prison workers cannot participate in executions.

If religious freedom means anything, it means that these people — just like Chipotle, Starbucks and everyone else in our society — are allowed to earn a living and run a business according to their values. In a tolerant society, we should just accept that our neighbors will have different beliefs, and that government-enforced conformity is rarely the best answer to this diversity.

Indeed, for as hip and trendy as it is to be “socially conscious” in business these days, we sure exhibit a peculiar apathy toward those whose consciences are informed by gods other than those of environmentalism, progressivism, and sexual revolution. Particular beliefs aside, anyone who holds to the flimsy notion that this could never happen to that — that Starbucks couldnever e the next Hobby Lobby —would do well to recognize that not only does power tend to corrupt, but such corruption tends to trickle around accordingly.

If we’re going to tell businesses they can either be for God or for profit, but not both, we should be prepared to accept the result: bars on the windows of economic martyrs and dollar signs everywhere else.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Can Pope Francis Deal With Toxic Contamination?
The bureaucracy of the Roman Curia is nothing new. When Pope John XXIII was asked how many people worked at the Vatican, he replied, “About half.” A great chuckle, but an unfortunate truth. The National Post’s Scott Barber shares the mess that Pope Francis is going to have to deal with: A bination of corruption, petence and tradition could stifle Pope Francis’ ability to rid the Catholic Church of scandal, Vatican analysts say. “This whole mess needs to be excavated...
What We Can Expect from Pope Francis
Michael Severance, operations manager of the Istituto Acton in Rome, recently wrote an article for the World Catholic Report explaining why Pope Francis was a historic choice and examining what we can expect from his papacy. He points out that “this past week proved a historic week of firsts:” We now have the first Jesuit pope. And the first pope named Francis. He is the first non-European pope since Gregory III, an eighth-century Syrian. And we now have the very...
Video: A Humble Pope
Last week, Acton president and co-founder, Rev. Robert Sirico, and operations manager of Istituto Acton, Michael Severance, were featured on Reuters TV discussing Pope Francis’ humility and frugality. ...
Audio: Kishore Jayabalan on Pope Francis’ Installation
Kishore Jayabalan, Director of Instituto Acton in Rome, joined host Michael Patrick Shiels on Michigan’s Big Show to discuss the mood in Rome on the day of Pope Francis’ Installation Mass. The theme of the day, according to Jayabalan, was one of “quiet, faithful, obedient service.” The Vatican estimates that between 150,000 and 200,000 people turned out for the event. Listen to the full interview here: ...
A Meat Grinder Which Destroys Lives: Pope Francis on Slavery
Pope Francis has already made it clear that he has a heart and mind for the poor. We’ve seen images of him washing the feet of AIDS patients, stopping traffic to bless a severely handicapped man in St. Peter’s Square, and reminding us from the first moments of his papacy to remember the poor. Beyond that, there is a certain population of the poor that Francis wants us to remember: those caught in human trafficking and slavery. The White House...
Rev. Sirico on ‘The Blaze’ to Discuss Pope Francis
The Blaze TV will be featuring the Rev. Robert Sirico and Rabbi Daniel Lapin on Wednesday, March 20. The hour-long program will focus on the election of Pope Francis, formerly Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio of Argentina. Pope Francis has already made several statements regarding the Church’s relationship with the Jewish people, and the Chief Rabbi of Rome, Riccardo di Segni, plans to attend the papal inauguration. Carol Glatz, of The CatholicHerald UK, writes: Abraham Foxman, national director of the Anti-Defamation...
Sen. Warren: Why Isn’t the Minimum Wage $22 an Hour?
In the United States we have approximately 314 million citizens. In the United States Senate, the upper house of our country’s bicameral legislature, there are exactly 100 senators. That means only 1 senator is selected for every 3.14 million people in the nation. Because two e from each state and the population is spread unevenly, the ratio of citizens to senators isn’t exact. Still, you’d think out of a pool of millions the chances are high that people selected for...
The Hart of the Matter on Trade With China
Today at Ethika Politika, I critique David Bentley Hart’s recent (non-)response to the critics of his attack on natural law in public discourse last month, appearing in the most recent issue of First Things. My article, “Hart’s (Non-)Response to His Critics: Trying to Have It Both Ways?” is a response to Hart’s recent article,“Si Fueris Romae.” While Hart’s most recent article may seem unrelated, it starts to sound remarkably similar to his article on natural law from last month about...
Pope Francis: A Different Type of Social Justice?
Alejandro Chafuen, President of the Atlas Economic Research Foundation, is hoping that newly-elected Pope Francis will be able to sort out the misunderstandings of what “social justice” means in the Church today. In today’s Forbes, Chafuen suggests that “social justice” has too often meant (especially in places like the pope’s home country of Argentina) taking from the rich and giving to the poor. Chafuen observes that the Jesuit order, to which Pope Francis belongs, has a long intellectual history when...
Does International Child Sponsorship Work?
In 1936, near the end of the Great Depression, Children International launched one of the earliest child sponsorship charities. Today, child sponsorship is one of the most significant forms of foreign aid. It’s estimated that there are over 8 million internationally sponsored children in the world. With the average monthly sponsorship level set at about $30 (not including other gifts sent to sponsored children), the flow of resources from wealthy countries to poor countries from international child sponsorships is about...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved