Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Bruce Edward Walker: ‘Shutting down discourse is justice denied’
Bruce Edward Walker: ‘Shutting down discourse is justice denied’
Nov 14, 2024 1:32 AM

Bruce Edward Walker recently wrote mentary for The Tampa Tribune entitled, Shutting Down Corporate Speech in the Name of Social Justice. He says that:

Corporate boardrooms arebeing caught up ina newwave of religious fervor sparkedbyclergy andmembers ofreligious ordersin search ofsocial justice. Alas, this movement is only superficially about the spirit.In truth,corporate directors pany executives are facinga very worldlymissionary effort bypriests, pastors, nuns and laypersonsarmed withproxy shareholder resolutionsthat advance politically liberal dogmas, including attempts to undermine the Supreme Court’sCitizens United ruling.

Enlisting members of the munity to this movement is simply disguising “leftist ideology in church vestments.”

The nuns and friars submitting the proxy resolutions are members of the New York City-basedInterfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility, which, for the past 41 years, has established itself as “the pioneer coalition of active shareowners whoview the management of their investments as a catalyst to promote justice and sustainability in the world.” The ICCR’s view of “justice and sustainability,” however, seems less grounded in Christian doctrine than talking points from MSNBC.

Theseresolutions, not surprisingly, list the amount of money spent by pany on “direct federal lobbying”using figures taken from Senate reports. What seems toupsetthereligious activists,or actually ICCR, is the lack of disclosure of “lobbying expenditures to influence legislation in states,” including “trade association payments” and “membership in tax-exempt organizations that write and endorse model legislation, such as the American Legislative Exchange Council.”

Walker fears that:

encouragingboards of directors”to prehensive disclosure related to direct, indirect and grassroots lobbying”efforts as noted in the ICCRproxy resolutions derivesfrom the desire to publicly shame the corporations in question for supporting groups that advocate in theirbest interests. Ultimately, the goal is toend these relationships altogether.Is this not an injustice, by any measure?

Because groups such as ALEC leantoward drafting free-market, lighter regulatorypolicysolutions, it can only be surmised that ICCR simply wants to shut down one side of the discourse with which it disagrees.In this alternate universe, justice apparently denotes big-government oversight of all aspects related to corporate speech, includingthecontents ofthatspeech.

There indeed exist many valid reasons for assuring the privacy of corporate donations to advocacy groups such as ALEC, which hasbeen a major target of liberal/progressive critics. From the corporate side, the effects of these shareholder campaigns could lead panies severing all connections withALEC and other advocacy groupsworking on their behalf.And, indeed, this has panies such asGeneral Motorsand Walmart, which cut their ties to the organization.

He concludes with this thought:

Shuttingdown discourse is justice denied. If the proxy shareholder resolutions put forth by ICCR members and other groups are successful, corporations will lose powerful voices that speak on their behalf. But the biggest losers will be thepeople who benefit most fromthe paniesthatprovide employment opportunities, engage in philanthropic efforts and pay taxes to munities to which they belong.

By all means, those groups represented by the ICCR should exercisethefreedomto express their opinions on any number of issues. But we as Americans— andespeciallyreligiousleaders —should champion freedom of speech in all its guises rather than support efforts to stifle it.

Bruce Edward Walker has written several posts on the Acton PowerBlog about social justice and the ICCR. Check out his posts here.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Open Source Software and Market Competition
The traditional Drupal logo Last week I attended Drupalcon Chicago 2011. Acton Institute’s website runs the Content Management System called Drupal. It is a highly customizable website publishing tool that powers around 1.7% of the Internet. Drupal scales: you can use it for a personal website, but very large outfits use Drupal including the White House and Grammy. As you may know, open source software is free. Anyone can download the package and begin using it or view the internal...
A Discussion of ‘A Call for Intergenerational Justice’
Last night Gideon Strauss of the Center for Public Justice was generous enough to join us for a public discussion of the recently-released document, “A Call for Intergenerational Justice: A Christian Proposal for the American Debt Crisis.” This document has occasioned a good deal of reflection here at the PowerBlog, and Gideon took the time to engage this reflection, introducing the context of the Call and answering questions about it. Gideon got to chide me for not signing the document...
Can the U.S. learn from Europe’s green mistakes?
Kenneth P. Green, of the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), recently examined green energy in Europe in an essay titled, “The Myth of Green Energy Jobs: The European Experience.” Green thoroughly analyzes the green industry in Europe while seeking to discover the reasons behind its current downward spiral. As readers discover, this is largely due to the green industry being unsustainable while heavily relying on government intervention and subsidies. Green uses the failing green industry in Europe to forewarn the United...
Social Justice and the ‘Third California’
In his New Geographer column on Forbes, Joel Kotkin looks at the “profound gap between the cities where people are moving to and the cities that hold all the political power” in California. Those living in the growing “Third California” — the state’s interior region — are increasingly shut out by political elites in San Francisco and other coastal cities. Kotkin observes that the “progressives” of the coast are “fundamentally anti-growth, less concerned with promoting broad-based economic growth — despite...
Green Patriarch: No Nukes
With the terrible human toll from Japan’s earthquake and tsunami catastrophe only now prehended, and the grave follow on crisis at the country’s nuclear power plants unfolding by the hour, the anti-nuclear power crowd has already begun issuing statements such as the one Greenpeace put out saying that “nuclear power cannot ever be safe.” Predictably, reports Geoffrey Lean in the Telegraph, “battle lines” are being drawn: On Saturday, some 50,000 anti-nuclear protesters formed a 27-mile human chain from Germany’s Neckarwestheim...
Japan Quake, Military Aid, and Shane Claiborne
Waking up to the devastation today in Japan was heartbreaking. Malcolm Foster, reporting for the AP, notes: A ferocious tsunami unleashed by Japan’s biggest recorded earthquake slammed into its eastern coast Friday, killing hundreds of people as it carried away ships, cars and homes, and triggered widespread fires that burned out of control. Reporting for Reuters, Patricia Zengerle and David Morgan’s headline reads: “U.S. readies relief for quake-hit ally Japan.” From their article: The Defense Department was preparing American forces...
Samuel Gregg: Business vs. the Market
In a new essay for Public Discourse, Acton Research Director Samuel Gregg explains why we shouldn’t only focus on public sector unions as examples of organizations that seek government power and taxpayer dollars to advance their ends. “A considerable portion of the munity is equally culpable,” Gregg writes. Excerpt: The attractions of business-government collusion are enhanced when the state’s involvement in the economy grows. This is partly a question of incentives. The larger the scope of government economic intervention, the...
Religion & Liberty: An Interview with Thomas C. Oden
Religion & Liberty’s winter issue featuring an interview with patristics scholar Thomas C. Oden is now available online. Oden, who is a Methodist, recalls for us the great quote by Methodist founder John Wesley on the Church Fathers: “The Fathers are the most mentators on Scripture, for they were nearest the fountain and were eminently endued with that Spirit by whom all Scripture was given.” Oden reminds us of the relevancy of patristics today, he says “You can hardly find...
Five Things
It’s been awhile since I’ve done a summary post of this kind, but there’s been a fair number of things of interest over the last week or so that are worthy of a quick highlight. So here’s an edition of the aptly named “Five Things” (HT): Carl Trueman reflects on his visit to the Acton Institute. Concerned about how his Republocrat credentials e across, Trueman says, “Despite my fears that I might be heavily outgunned at Acton, the seminar actually...
A Suggestion for Rounding Out ‘A Call for Intergenerational Justice’
I’d like to thank Gideon Strauss of the Center for Public Justice and Jordan Ballor of the Acton Institute for their gracious and thoughtful contributions to the discussion of “A Call for Intergenerational Justice” at last night’s Open Mic Night in Grand Rapids. It was an excellent example of the kind of spirited and good natured dialogue we need in confronting the problems of poverty and the national debt. Earlier this week I pointed out that there was indeed a...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved