Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Book review: ‘Reckoning with Race: America’s Failure’ by Gene Dattel
Book review: ‘Reckoning with Race: America’s Failure’ by Gene Dattel
Jul 18, 2025 8:11 PM

Reckoning with Race: America’s Failure. Gene Dattel.

Encounter Books, 2017. 312 pages.

Long before they exploded into violence at Charlottesville, race relations seemed so intractable that Alexis de Tocqueville wrote “the white and black races will [never] … be upon an equal footing.” Nearly two centuries later, this seems to be another doleful example of Tocqueville’s prescience.

In Reckoning with Race: America’s Failure, which is to be released later this month, Gene Dattel chooses to concentrate on what he dubs “the fulcrum of this issue: the entrance of most black Americans into the economic mainstream.” He plumbs the importance of education as a preparation for economic life. But he grounds both in the irreplaceable bedrock of a free and virtuous society.

Religious readers may be surprised to learn that blacks’ subordinate status came, in part, from false religious teachings about the Book of Genesis. An article in theConnecticut Journal in 1774 stated forthrightly that “God formed [blacks] … mon with horses, oxygen, dogs &c. for the white people alone, to be used by them either for pleasure or to labor with other beasts.” Similarly, Mississippi politician Sergeant S. Prentiss said in 1836 on the floor of the state legislature that slavery is “the legitimate condition of the African race, as authorized both by the laws of God and the dictates of reason.” Today, notions of blacks being pre-Adamite creatures, formed on the fifth day of creation with the “beasts of the field,” are confined to the fever swamps of the minuscule Identity Christian movement. The reference highlights the indispensable role traditional exegesis, correct anthropology, and a consequent respect for human dignity play in promoting liberty.

Blacks found themselves condemned to an existence as mere objects rather than subjects. Dattel, a financial historian and former investment banker, shows in exquisite detail how economic factors definitively shaped the black experience. Brought to this country as human chattel, slaves were denied any education that would allow them to escape the plantation system, before or after emancipation. Northern politicians wanted black slaves freed – and contained to the South. Blacks’ presence was only desired when leaders such as Massachusetts Governor John Andrew wished to use them to fulfill his state’s military quota without drafting whites.

Various institutions, especially the black church, tried to find a path into the economic mainstream. In 1831, Reverend Simeon S. Jocelyn tried to open a vocational education college for blacks in New Haven, Connecticut – but town residents, including Yale University, shut him down. Labor shortages created by World War I began the Great Migration northward, yet economic codes – and barriers preventing blacks from taking mercial courses” – artificially restricted most to low-paying menial work more subtly than Jim Crow laws or the apartheid color bar.

When allowed to flourish, free enterprise benefited members of all “races.” Madam C.J. Walker presided over an all-black cosmetics empire that made her $600,000 during her lifetime. She used the money to fund Tuskegee Institute, and in 1917 she became a member of the NAACP’s mittee. Another heroine, “Pigs’ Feet Mary,” began accumulating her $375,000 fortune by selling chitterlings, corn, and pigs’ feet on the sidewalk from a baby carriage.

But economic opportunities within the segregated munity proved too narrow to create widespread prosperity. Dattel repeatedly states that businesses simply cannot generate enough revenue if they are confined to a racial and economic minority. As Jack Kemp and Jesse Jackson would later agree, “Capitalism without capital is nothing but an ‘ism.’”

The debate over how to move forward has centered on whether to embrace the free market or advocate greater government intervention and regimentation. Dattel personifies these forces in the persons of Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. Du Bois. In 1895, Washington encouraged blacks to flourish in whatever economic avenues are available to them, since “no race that has anything to contribute to the markets of the world is long in any degree ostracized.” By so doing, blacks could “rise to the level of owning stores, operating factories.” Frederick Douglass, too, advised blacks in 1853, to “learn not only to black boots but to make them.”Decades earlier, nationwide ethnic conventions longed for the day that blacks would “form panies and mutual-savings banks.”

Du Bois advocated a “fuzzy brand of Marxism,” once writing, “Folks ain’t got no right to things they don’t need.” Du Bois recognized family breakdown within the munity as a social malady, but blamed it on “economic hindrances to sound moral life.”

As he weaves his engrossing narrative Dattel, who explored this territory before in Cotton and the Making of America, underscores the importance of national economic growth lying beneath the surface of each historical development. In response to the long hot summer of 1967, when no fewer than 159 race riots roiled the nation, the Kerner Report suggested “creating one million new jobs in the public sector in three years, creating one million new jobs in the private sector in three years … [and] encouraging business ownership in the ghetto.” The funding for such programs e from unspecified “economic growth.”

Christians and all people of goodwill who seek racial reconciliation should pursue fiscal policies that expand the nation’s economic assets. Whether the individual sides with Washington’s view emphasizing initiative or Du Bois’ redistribution, resources must first exist. Free markets, more expansive trade, lighter regulations, and a flatter, broader tax code free entrepreneurs to generate wealth. The jobs they create, in turn, liberate each individual to offer his or her God-given gifts to the world.

Instead, the nation has instituted “myriad federal programs [that] have failed to transform employment for blacks in the workforce.” Failing schools – which he believes should petition from charter schools – place job security above children’s economic future. Further, college-bound blacks receive little guidance toward better paying jobs. A 2016 study from Georgetown University found blacks clustered in “lower-paying majors.”

Along the way, Dattel notes, single-parent households, divorce rates, and abandonment have expanded in tandem with the welfare state. A family-centered culture that encourages virtue, thrift, and “responsibility,” he writes, must replace berating middle-class values. He continually returns to the point, in his own words and through others, that the black church alone can instill the virtuous and hopeful order necessary to end four centuries of needlessly squandered human capital.

Reckoning with Race suffers, as well as benefits, from the author’s peculiar background. As a Southerner educated in the Ivy League, Dattel clearly intends to demythologize the North as a bastion of racially progressive thought and practice. It is unclear such an undertaking is necessary in the present context, particularly in a work of limited scope. Moreover, he spends pages at a time poring over the racial views of Northern figures who, we find at the end of his rabbit trails, held views entirely conventional for their day. This form of sectional presentism adds little to the book.

Dattel could have broadened his cultural critique menting more upon black criticism of the West as a whole. “Freedom and a high standard of living are products of Western civilization,” he writes. He notes that Andrew Young wondered aloud in 1970 if American blacks weren’t “the revolutionary vanguard that God has ordained to destroy” Western civilization – something he regarded as, on balance, desirable. Young would go on to serve as Jimmy Carter’s ambassador to the UN before ing president of the National Council of Churches. Such assessments merit a fuller response in an age when universities replace the writings of Plato with those of Frantz Fanon.

Like mentators, Dattel is better at analyzing the problem than providing concrete solutions. But his conclusions are presented in a remarkably unmodulated and prescriptive tone. “Economic advancement must be the number one goal for black Americans,” he writes. “If black family structure continues in its present form, educational and vocational obstacles may be virtually insurmountable.” In an age where dialogue has been replaced with admonitions to “check your privilege,” that bustible.

Clearly Dattel – a white Southerner – cannot hope to escape the same criticism leveled against Barack Obama, Don Lemon, and Bill Cosby. One must hope against hope that such criticisms will focus on the substance of his arguments, not the identity of the person making them. If they do, they will find that Dattel has offered his readers a well-documented account of how the intertwining cords of culture, virtue, and economic hope may ease America’s most enduring fault line.

Pierce. This photo has been cropped. CC BY 2.0.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
On Call with Dr. Pamela Casson
Dr. Pamela Casson, a pediatrician in Colorado Springs, knows what it means literally to be “On Call.” This week she shares with us in this video interview with Jon Hirst how she sees God working through her in her work with families, children and the world around her. Thank you Pamela for giving us an inside look at how you see your work as blessing the world. ...
Rev. Sirico on Life, Work, and Human Flourishing
J.Q. Tomanek of Ignitum Today interviewed Rev. Sirico about life, work, human flourishing, and his new book, Defending the Free Market: JQ Tomanek: Back in the day, holiness was misinterpreted as a cleric or religious life thing. How can a lay Catholic practice their faith? What are some ways to sanctify our work as lay Catholics? Is “ora et labora” just a monk thing? Reverend Sirico: Yes, religious people are often tempted to e so “heavenly minded they are no...
How were people On Call in Culture 165 years ago?
What is so special about 1837? That was the year Abraham Kuyper was born. September 29th is his 165th birthday. So we thought we would go back to 1837 and see how people were being On Call in Culture back then. We don’t know if they were all believers on a mission to bless the world, but by seeing what was going on 165 years ago, we hope you are encouraged to engage your world in 2012! How did people...
Dodd-Frank: The Other Serious Threat
At least es at us head on. The greater legislative threat may be the one that most Americans have never heard of. Economist Scott Powell and Acton friend Jay Richards explain in a new piece in Barron’s: While Obamacare received more attention, the Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, also known as Dodd-Frank after its Senate and House sponsors, … unleashed a new regulatory body, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, to operate with unprecedented power. Dodd-Frank became law in...
Did 2,362 Millionaires Get Unemployment Checks in 2009? (Answer: Yes they did.)
The Congressional Research Service (CRS), a group that works exclusively for the U.S. Congress, issued a report with one of the greatest titles I’ve ever seen on a government document: Receipt of Unemployment Insurance by e Unemployed Workers (“Millionaires”) Now the first nine words are nothing special, typical policy-wonk speak. But whoever added in the word “millionaires” with scare quotes and parentheses is a genius. Most people would have been nodding off around the word “Insurance” but seeing millionaires (that’s...
Stop Apologizing for Our Liberties
You cannot apologize to a fanatic, says Lee Harris. It only serves to convince him that he was right all along: The last few weeks have witnessed a peculiar and disturbing spectacle: An American administration that has spent a great deal of time and energy apologizing for our liberties—in particular, for what many would regard as the foundation of all our other liberties, namely, the freedom to express our minds as we see fit. This signature freedom, of which Americans...
Markets and culture: A time to play, a time to pray
Faced with the prospect of a professional athletic career, a nearly-half million dollar salary, and a perfect lady, what’s not to like? Apparently, for Grant Desme, it was the noise and unrest of the world. Can a culture of life and the noise and tumult of the marketplace co-exist? Rev. Robert Sirico, reflecting on this, says they can, so long as it is not a place where: [C]apitalism…places the human person at the mercy of blind economic forces…What we propose,...
Counting the Profit of a Third Party Choice
Joe Carter recently highlighted the discussion at Ethika Politika, the journal of the Center for Morality in Public Life, about the value of (not) voting, particularly the suggestion by Andrew Haines that in some cases there is a moral duty not to vote. This morning I respond with an analysis of the consequences of not voting, ultimately arguing that one must not neglect to count the cost of abstaining to vote for any particular office. One issue, however, that I...
Want to Help the Poor? Promote a Free Market in Health Care
Want to help the poor? Promote a free market in health care. That’s the argument made by John C. Goodman, author of the new book Priceless: Curing the Healthcare Crisis. Timothy Dalrymple recently talked with Goodman about the best approach for restoring free-market pricing mechanisms into the market for medical care and health insurance: Aren’t there some people, however, who have little of money and lots of time, and would prefer to wait in order to receive cheaper care? There...
Is it really ‘aid’ if it goes to relatively wealthy nations?
Alan Duncan, an aid minister in the UK, says his government is “forced” to hand over large amounts of money to the EU’s foreign aid budget, but has no say in how the money is spent. The problem is that much of the $2 billion+ “aid” money (one-sixth of the British budget) goes to projects such as making a Moroccan water park more eco-friendly, an art project in St. Petersburg, and building a hotel and plex in Barbados. Britain’s International...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved