Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Bernie Sanders, jobs, and what work really is
Bernie Sanders, jobs, and what work really is
Mar 17, 2025 9:56 AM

‘Bernie Sanders at a rally in New Orleans, Louisiana, July 26, 2015’ by Nick Solari CC BY-SA 2.0

Last month the Washington Post reported, “Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) will announce a plan for the federal government to guarantee a jobpaying $15 an hour and health-carebenefits to every Americanworker “who wants or needs one,”…” These jobs would be the product of hundreds of government projects initiated in, “…infrastructure, care giving, the environment, education and other goals.” The projects, their costs, and how they would be financed have yet to be disclosed. While there are many economic critiques of such schemes which should be considered (See Economics in One Lesson particularly the chapters ‘Public Works Mean Taxes’, ‘Taxes Discourage Production’, and ‘Spread-the-work Schemes’) the most fundamental critique is that jobs are not simply black boxes from which wages and benefits emerge but a form of service rendered to others.

We have a tendency to plex phenomena to their effects. Playing basketball es merely scoring points, a healthy diet es merely the avoidance of carbohydrates, and religion es merely something we do in weekly worship. Such reductions are partially true: you can’t win a basketball game without points, an all pasta diet will make you fat, and worship obligations are indeed obligatory (See Exodus 20:8-11). But these reductions are also misleading: defense wins championships, vegetables are also carbohydrates, and prayer should be unceasing (See 1 Thessalonians 5:17).

Economists are not free from making these sorts of misleading reductions. Economist Arnold Kling’s excellent book, Specialization and Trade: A Re-introduction to Economics, was written in part to challenge economists who see the economy as nothing more than a GDP factory to be manipulated and prodded into growth for growth’s sake. For Kling the economy isn’t simply a matter of equations but changing patterns of specialization and trade, the patterns of certain kinds of human relationships.

On an individual level many of these relationships are jobs: patterns of work paid for by employers in the form of, among other things, wages and benefits. In his book Work: The Meaning of Your Life Lester DeKoster states, “Work is the form in which we make ourselves useful to others.” It is precisely because the worker is useful that he is worthy of his hire. A job is not merely a wage factory.

Workers need jobs, they should want them, they should pensated for the value of their work, and that work must also render useful service to their employers. Jobs should not exist for their own sake. Senator Sanders is right in thinking jobs are important but they are more than wage factories; jobs must be meaningful to both employer and employee and animated by a spirit of service. Bringing employers and employees together in forms of meaningful and mutual service is something that we should all strive for but government make-work programs do not foster sustainable patterns of specialization and trade.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Santa and the ultimate Fairy Tale
Of course, Santa is based on a historical character. And in many (but certainly not all!) ways, he points forward to Jesus Christ. But in a broader sense, God has created a mystical, mythical, and magical world– that can be overdone or mis-imagined. That said, the mon error is to under-do or under-imagine– out of our “modern” heritage and tainted worldview. I’ve blogged on this quite a few times– and three times in the past month, in noting the 100th...
Economic Justice for All Revisited
Catching up on “Revisiting the 1986 economic pastoral”, an article from October in the National Catholic Reporter: The bishops’ point “that Catholics’ moral life cannot be separated entirely from their economic life has relevance for what we’re going through now,” said Kevin Schmiesing, research fellow for the Acton Institute, a proponent of free markets. “Unless you believe there is no ponent to this, that there’s no failure of responsibility, that there’s no greed at work, that those kinds of moral...
Ponnuru on Ponzi and Pyramids
Ramesh Ponnuru says Social Security is worse than a Ponzi scheme. He’s right. It’s more like an inter-generational pyramid scheme, a pyramid tipped on its side… To be sustainable, over time (T) it has to take more from more people (thus a three-dimensional pyramid rather than a two-dimensional triangle. It’s really exponential rather than multiplicative). Social Security. In case you forgot, it still needs fixing. This Christmas, think about the rather unpleasant gift we’ll be leaving the generations that follow...
Soul Searching at Yeshiva U.
In “Betrayed by Madoff, Yeshiva U. Adds a Lesson,” the New York Times interviews students and teachers at the New York University which was closely linked to Bernard Madoff, the financier who has been charged by federal prosecutors with orchestrating a $50 billion Ponzi scheme fraud. In Intermediate Accounting I, undergraduates analyzed how he seemingly tap-danced around the Securities and Exchange Commission. In Rabbi Benjamin Blech’s philosophy of Jewish law course, students pondered whether Jewish values had been distorted to...
Reading Russell Kirk
It’s the end of the year, so the book lists are out. I’m thinking about conservative icon Russell Kirk. If you want a really enjoyable and edifying read, I mend you begin with The Roots of American Order. That book will give you an understandable and historically grounded sense of what “ordered liberty” means. It will also open the mysteries of Kirk wide to the uninitiated reader. The prose is lively. Highly readable. Kirk is more widely known for the...
Acton Commentary: Selfless Giving and Tempered Trading
In this season of giving, Kevin Schmiesing looks at another form of exchange — trade. He observes that mercial activity “is not an exercise in selfishness, but the practice of properly ordered self-interest, which is of necessity tempered by the wants and needs of others.” Read mentary over at the Acton website and e back to share ments. ...
The Acton Website gets a New Look
Today saw the launch of a sharp new look for the Acton Institute website. This new iteration of the website puts content first, with a very uncluttered, fresh look. It also sports some of the latest and greatest in web technology, but I’ll spare you the geekspeak and let you discover all of the bells and whistles for yourself. We hope that you’ll continue to enjoy the Acton website and the rich collection of articles and resources that it provides....
O Holy Night
O Holy night, the stars are brightly shining. It is the night of our dear Saviour’s birth. Long lay the world in sin and error pining, Till he appeared and the soul felt its worth. A thrill of hope the weary world rejoices, For yonder breaks a new and glorious morn. Fall on your knees! Oh hear the angel voices! Oh night divine! Oh night when Christ was born! Oh night divine! Oh night! Oh night divine! Chains shall he...
J. Daryl Charles on the Revival of Natural Law
In the latest volume of the Mars Hill Audio Journal, host Ken Myers talks with J. Daryl Charles, author of Retrieving the Natural Law: A Return to Moral First Things (Eerdmans, 2008). Charles is associate professor of Christian Studies at Union University, and spent the 2007-2008 year as William E. Simon Visiting Fellow in Religion and Public Life in the James Madison Program at Princeton University. I had the pleasure of meeting Ken Myers at this year’s GodblogCon and am...
The Naughty List
You can view the most recent list of panies that have received bailout assistance from the federal government via the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008 (EESA), executed through measures like the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP), here (PDF updated 12/16/08). I’m thinking about adding panies to my own personal “naughty” list. Visit the EESA homepage, where you can sign up for EESA e-mail updates as your tax dollars are spent for you. “How is this money being spent?” you...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved