Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Bailouts, moral hazards, and the scapegoating of the taxpayer
Bailouts, moral hazards, and the scapegoating of the taxpayer
Jan 21, 2026 2:55 PM

If pandering is the politicians’pastime, then we owe a special debt of gratitude to those who resist this seemingly irresistible force. Today, UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson confirmed that he refused to extenda £150 million government bailout to preventThomas Cook, the world’s oldest travel agency, from going bankrupt.

Moreover, the prime minister explained his actions in both economic and moral terms.

“It is perfectly true that a request was made to the government for a subvention of about £150 million​,” or $187 million U.S.,saidPM Johnson during a flight to the UN General Assembly early Monday morning.

“Clearly, that is a lot of taxpayers’ money,” he continued, adding that bailing out the pany “sets up … a moral hazard in the case of future mercial difficulties panies face.”

National leaders need to find ways businesses “can protect themselves from such bankruptcies in [the] future” and put systems in place to “make sure [they] don’t in the e to thetaxpayerfor help.”

Johnson has faced significantbacklashfrom Labour Party and union leaders, who say he should have saved pany’s 9,000 UK jobs.

“To just stand to one side and watch this number of jobs go” is not “wise government,” saidJohn McDonnell. The Labour Party Shadow Chancellor, who calls himself a “Marxist,” accused Johnson of “ideological bias.”

Others have wondered why, if previous governments could bail out banks during the financial crisis, Johnson would not do the same for the 178-year-old pany. But their objections prove Johnson’s point.

A “moral hazard” creates an incentive for pany to take risks, because it will not bear the full consequences of its poor decisions. Bailouts on either side of the Atlantic encourage CEOs to take high-stakes gambles with their shareholders’ money. If the risk pays off, pany stands to make windfall profits, shared through higher dividend checks. But if it fails, the government will stabilize pany’s bottom line with an infusion of taxpayers’ dollars.

Crony capitalism has single-handedly soured an entire generation on “capitalism” – and rightly so. The knowledge that taxpayers will bailout large corporations lets panies “socialize the losses and privatize the gains,”saidJoseph Stiglitz, a harsh critic of capitalism and winner of the Nobel Prize in economics. Occupy Wall Street protesters – and average Americans – oftenasked, “Where’s my bailout?” Today’s socialist leaders ask, if the government picks winners and losers, why does it always pick Wall Street over Main Street?

Forcing taxpayers to foot the bill for failed corporate decisions presents other problems, to be sure. The government has no constitutional authority to use federal money to prop up a private corporation. Bailouts reward bad behavior by shielding people from the consequences of their own actions. Because bailouts only go panies deemed “too big to fail,” they favor large corporations over their small and petitors. Politicians reward politically panies – connections often forged with political donations. This creates a fiscal cycle that expropriates taxpayers’ dollars from private individuals, gives them to large (and poorly run) businesses, then helps re-elect the politicians who initiatied the process. This is a cozy relationship for two of the three parties.

But the biggest drawback of government bailouts is incalculable: It is the impact moral hazards have on future behavior.

Some have criticized Boris Johnson for not giving Thomas Cook£150 million, because the airline’s collapse left approximately 150,000 UK citizensstrandedabroad, and the government will pay an estimated£100 million to bring them home.“The government’s ‘do nothing’ attitude has left workers and customers high and dry while landing taxpayers with a bill of hundreds of millions of pounds,” said Len McCluskey, general secretary of the UK-based union Unite.

Why, critics ask, did Johnson not “save” pany, rather than pay nearly as much money in airfare? A little infusion may have kept pany solvent until it could bebought outby the Chinese conglomerate Fosun International, they argue.

But the £100 million is a one-time cost. Thomas Cook posted a £1.5 billion loss in May and has hemorrhaged money for years, meaning this bailout would not have been the last. Worse, it would have set the precedent that any pany of sufficient size could turn to the government during financial downturns and expect to continue business-as-usual.

By panies to engage in bad – and sometimes morally questionable – business decisions, the government would e an ethical partaker in those decisions. Moral guides say someone who provokes another person to sinsharesin that person’s guilt.

But in the case of endless corporate crashes and bailouts, the situation is more akin to a scapegoat. It is innocent taxpayers who pay the price for others’ iniquity.

Lee. This photo has been cropped.CC BY 2.0.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
France urges actions against Iran
France’s foreign minister, Philippe Douste-Blazy, said that Iran’s move to resume its nuclear activities could spark a “major international crisis,” increasing the pressure on Tehran to return to the negotiating table or risk facing sanctions. France is urging European negotiators to propose a meeting of the International Atomic Energy Agency’s council of governors. “If the Iranians still do not accept what the council of governors propose, then the munity must turn to the Security Council” and “we will see what...
Exchange on globalization and labor
From last week’s McLaughlin Group (July 30), an exchange between Pat Buchanan and Mort Zuckerman on the AFL-CIO split: MR. BUCHANAN: There’s no doubt it is a blow to the Democrats. And what Eleanor said is very important earlier. The future of the labor movement is in service workers and it’s government workers, John, because the industrial unions are dying. We are exporting all of their jobs overseas, whether it’s textile or steel or (atomic?) workers or auto workers. All...
Al Gore launches network
Al Gore’s new Current TV network seeks to be “the television home page for the Internet generation,” the former vice-president said. With its debut today, Current TV seeks to be a more hip and cutting-edge form of presenting the news. “I think the reality of the network will speak for itself,” Gore told reporters. “It’s not intended to be partisan in any way and not intended to be ideological.” Sure thing Mr. Gore. Of course a network you are debuting...
Dying by the sword
Two recent news items of interest, the timing of which seems serendipitous: “U.S. Muslim Scholars Issue Edict Against Terrorism” “IRA Ending Longtime ‘Armed Campaign'” ...
Fruitful math
Here’s a view of procreation that doesn’t line up with the UN-sponsored “World Population Day”. In the midst of a discussion about a Jewish tradition mandating that each couple has at least one male and one female child, Bryan Caplan at EconLog writes, I’m on the record in favor of having more kids. I believe that, in most cases, both individuals and society would be better off if families had three or four. A lot of people have small families...
The birth of space tourism
This has been a momentous week for manned space exploration. First, NASA returned to flight with Tuesday’s launch of the Space Shuttle Discovery, which was almost immediately followed by a return to not flying, as safety concerns will be grounding the shuttle fleet once again. The whirlwind of activity has rekindled the debate over the future of the Space Shuttle program and the government’s manned space flight in general. But in the end, the space news that this week may...
Christians countering corruption
From ENI: Nigerian president wants Church to nurture God-fearing politicians Lagos (ENI). Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo, lamenting poor leadership and corruption among public officers in his country, has urged churches to help nurture political leaders who are honest, hardworking, visionary, and inspiring. “The Church has a major role to play in identifying, nurturing, promoting and guiding such leaders at all levels of our society and our polity,” Obasanjo said in Lagos at the laying of the foundation stone of a...
Dead man’s hand
On this date in 1876, Wild Bill Hickok was killed, shot dead from behind by Jack McCall while playing poker. He held a pair of aces & a pair of 8s, forever giving bination the nickname “Dead Man’s Hand.” Poker e a long way since then, ing a global multi-million dollar industry. There’s a good discussion over at World Magazine Blog, asking where parents should “draw the line,” given the rising popularity of poker among youth. This story from CBS’s...
Antiochian orthodox to quit NCC
The terminal politicization of the National Council of Churches has led a major Orthodox jurisdiction to throw in the towel. The Antiochian Orthodox Church, meeting for its bi-annual convention in Dearborn, Mich., has “voted overwhelmingly” to leave the ecumenical body led by Rev. Bob Edgar, a former Democrat congressman. The news has been posted on Touchstone Magazine’s Mere Comments blog, and was phoned in by a correspondent for Ancient Faith Radio who was on the scene in Dearborn. Metropolitan Philip...
Culture of litigation infects the Church
The current issue of Christianity Today magazine examines the lack of discipline in evangelical churches, and is presenting the themed articles in a series on its website. The litigious nature of American culture has e one of the great contributing factors to the decline of church discipline. A brief article by Ken Sande, an attorney who serves as president of Peacemaker Ministries, testifies to this reality. In “Keeping the Lawyers at Bay,” Sande writes that one way bat the tendency...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved