Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
ATMs, bank tellers, and the automation paradox
ATMs, bank tellers, and the automation paradox
Dec 6, 2025 11:29 AM

In September 1969 the Chemical Bank branch in Rockville Center, New York opened the first automatic teller machines. The first ATM was only able to give out cash, but by 1971 the machine could handle multiple functions, including providing customers’ account balances. The machine could do the job that was once reserved for human tellers. Over the next three decades, the number of ATMs increased exponentially. Today there are about 400,000 ATMs across America.

You can probably imagine what happened to bank teller jobs, can’t you? Their numbers increased.

What? That’s not what you expected? You thought the increase in ATMs would reduce the need for human tellers? As James Bessen explains,

What happened?Well, the average bank branch in an urban area required about 21 tellers. That was cut because of the ATM machine to about 13 tellers. But that meant it was cheaper to operate a branch. Well, banks wanted, in part because of deregulation but just for deregulation but just for basic marketing reasons, to increase the number of branch offices. And when it became cheaper to do so, demand for branch offices increased. And as a result, demand for bank tellers increased.And it increased enough to offset the labor-saving losses of jobs that would have otherwise occurred. So, again, it was one of these more dynamic things where the labor-saving technology actually createdmorejobs.

While technology can and does destroy some jobs (such as in agriculture), this automation paradox—that labor-saving technology can createmorejobs than it destroys—recurs often in the history of technology. And overall, as Christopher Mims notes, society as a e out ahead:

It’s true that technology alters the quality, as well as the quantity, of jobs. Ian Stewart, chief U.K. economist at Deloitte LLP in the U.K., co-wrote a paper last year that used census data as far back as the late 1700s to examine the changing nature of jobs in the U.K., cradle of the industrial revolution.

The authors found big increases in both low-paying and high-paying jobs. There are more barbers and barkeepers. But there also are more accountants and nurses, reflecting the plexity of the modern economy.

Paradoxically, says Mr. Stewart, many of the fields most transformed by technology have produced the biggest increases in employment, from medicine to management consulting. “What we saw was that machines and people were plementary,” he says.

What this means for America is that technology will likely make us all better off while making may others worse off—at least temporarily. We need to find creative ways to retrain workers for new opportunities. But just as importantly, we need to be realistic about what jobs have been permanently eliminated (such as farm labor) and which will be enhanced by technology (such as bank tellers).

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Why Superman is Bad for the Economy
In the new movie Man of Steel, Superman engages in a fight with his fellow aliens from Krypton that causes significant damage to Metropolis. Disaster expert Charles Watson estimates the costs of the physical damage done to the city to be about $2 trillion. To put that in context, 9/11’s physical damage cost $55 billion, with a further economic impact of $123 billion. What would be the impact of Superman’s fight on the economy? According to some liberal economists, it...
Family Breakdown, Economic Decline, and the Search for Spiritual Capital
When es to integrating family and vocation, modernity has introduced plenty of opportunity. But it has also produced its own set of challenges. Though our newfound array of choices can help further our callings and empower our contributions to society, it can also distract us away from the universe beyond ourselves. Thus far, I’ve limited my wariness on such matters to the more philosophical and theological realms — those areas where our culture of choice threatens to pollute our thinking...
Bavinck on Marriage and Cultural Reformation
The Dutch Reformed theologian Herman Bavinck has some wise words for reform of cultural institutions, notably marriage and family, in his exploration of The Christian Family: All good, enduring reformation begins with ourselves and takes its starting point in one’s own heart and life. If family life is indeed being threatened from all sides today, then there is nothing better for each person to be doing than immediately to begin reforming within one’s own circle and begin to rebuff with...
Proxy Shareholders Losing Their Religion
Perhaps nothing invigorates the left more than climate change and the exercise of free speech in the political arena – imagine bined dyspepsia when these two issues converge. This is what is occurring with regrettable frequency as Walden Asset Management, Ceres and the Interfaith Council on Corporate Relations have joined a rogue’s gallery of progressive organizations issuing proxy shareholder resolutions urging a variety panies to disassociate from the American Legislative Exchange Council. On June 25, Ernst & Young issued a...
Youth Unemployment: Are we Becoming Europe?
Alejandro Chafuen, president and chief executive officer of the Atlas Economic Research Foundation and board member of the Acton Institute, recently wrote a piece for discussing youth unemployment in the United States. According to the latest report, U.S. youth unemployment is at 16.2 percent which is more than double the adult unemployment rate. The unemployment rate for youth in Europe is currently at 24 percent. Chafuen asks, “Can we learn from the European experience?” Using piled by the economic freedom...
Religious Liberty and the Regulatory Road to Serfdom
Perhaps for the first time in American history, orthodox and traditional Jews, Christians, Muslims, Buddhists, Hindus, and others may need to form a new alliance in order to defend their religious liberties in an America that’s increasingly less tolerant of principled diversity. Religious and cultural progressives, secularists, and militant atheists pose a significant threat to religious freedom all in the name of “fairness.” What is not “unfair” is that munities are not free to not embrace cultural morality. In ing...
Community, Dignity, and Restoration Through Entrepreneurship
Last month, I had the pleasure of interviewing the folks at Neighborhood Film Company, pany that melds for-profit with non-profit to train, mentor, and employ adults in recovery through the process of filmmaking. This week, Tim Høiland has an article for Christianity Today’s This is Our City project that expands on NFCo.’s story, digging deeper into the ins and outs of their business model and further exploring the dynamics of munity-oriented approach. Though big can sometimes be better, the founders...
Chaplains Concerned About Supreme Court’s DOMA Ruling
The Chaplain Alliance for Religious Liberty, an organization of chaplain endorsers representing more than 2,000 current chaplains actively serving the armed forces, is concerned about the Supreme Court’s decision today to strike down a key provision of the Defense of Marriage Act. The Chaplain Alliance calls on Congress to pass enhanced religious liberty protections for all military personnel. “The court’s unfortunate decision to strike down the federal definition of marriage highlights the need for the religious liberty protections recently passed...
Report: ‘A Clamp-Down on Religious Liberty’
From a June 22 CNA/EWTN news article on the 2013 National Religious Freedom Conference in Washington, sponsored by the Ethics and Public Policy Center’s American Religious Freedom Program. The Very Reverend Dr. Chad Hatfield, Chancellor of St. Vladimir’s Orthodox Theological Seminary, echoed the Rabbi Cohen’s statements, telling CNA that “I think that there is a clamp-down on religious liberty in this country, but it’s so incredibly simple that we aren’t catching the signs.” “If one religious identity’s freedoms are taken,...
Commentary: Can America Remain the Land of Religious Liberty?
There is little doubt that America is moving further away from the kind of broad and liberal religious freedom that was championed during the founding period. In terms of intellectual thought, that period was certainly the high water mark for religious liberty around the globe. As Americans celebrate their freedoms and Independence next week, I seek to answer the question in this mentary about America’s ability to remain the land of religious liberty. Sadly, the outlook is rather bleak, and...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved