Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Appreciating the importance of vocational education
Appreciating the importance of vocational education
Sep 15, 2025 4:50 AM

If there is one thing young people believe in collectively, it is their individuality. “No two people are alike,” the refrain goes. But in the age of Common Core, educational systems too often treat all students alike, glossing over their unique skills and abilities. A top-down, cookie-cutter curriculum and the decline of vocational education have left too many children, on both sides of the Atlantic, without an ability to exercise their gifts.

Erik Lidström, who has written extensively on educational policies in Europe, charts the processin a new essay on theReligion & Liberty Transatlanticwebsite. In “The sad death of vocational education,” he looks at how new educational policies effectively locked talented young people out of the workforce. In a sweeping historical narrative he notes that – in his native Sweden, as in the United States – literacy antedated the federal government’s intervention in curricula:

Sweden began implementing government schools for the general population from 1842 onwards. Children started school at age seven, and schooling pulsory for six years. The schools employed traditional teaching methods, and by the time students were 12 or 13 years old, they knew more, in total than those who today finish high school (albeit in different subjects).On average they knew how to read and write, in addition to algebra, history, and civics – all arguably better than their modern, 19-year-old counterparts.

In the 1950s, though, “experts” began de-emphasizing vocational education, adding years of “abstract and theoretical” education. The changes caused those students who are more interested in technical fields to tune out – and to disrupt the studies of their college-bound classmates. Everyone suffered,Lidström wrote:

In contrast [to the pre-Fifties era], lecturers at Uppsala Universitywrotethat, in 2013, “Among the students e to us right from high school, a majority has problems with the language.” Elsewhere, half of those who begin high schooldo not masterthe mathematics they were supposed to learn between the ages of 10 and 12.

Under the new experts, technical jobs were presented as less prestigious, valuable, and fulfilling than “intellectual” jobs in “the professions.” Readers will see the same phenomenon at work in the United States.Mike Rowe once said such jobs are practically considered“vocational consolation prizes.”

“Because of the destructive policies of “experts” and politicians, it has e exceedingly difficult to e a good tradesman,”Lidström writes.

Yet those professions have lifted generations out of poverty – and that is itself sometimes the genesis of the opposition. In 1831, when Reverend Simeon S. Jocelyn tried to open a vocational college for blacks in New Haven, Connecticut – town residents, including Yale University, shut him down. The infamous post-Reconstruction Black Codes existed in no small part to petition from black laborers – in the process raising white wages (and consumers’ costs).

Modern antipathy to technical work was not shared by Martin Luther King Jr., who said, “All labor that uplifts humanity has dignity and importance.” Lidström agrees, writing:

There are no “higher” and “lower” vocations in life. The academic may enjoy a higher social status in some circles. But that person has not achieved a more praiseworthy function than the plumber or the carpenter. In any modern economy, there aretens of thousands of different jobsto be done. All are necessary, and if done right, all praiseworthy. …

Finding our niche in life, our vocation, is never easy, and some achieve this more perfectly than others. But our work creates mutually beneficial relationships with others. We continuously adjust to their desires, they to ours, and gradually we all more-or-less find our ways.

The new transatlantic emphasis on apprenticeshipsmay begin to correct course and and help more young people find out how to serve others in their own unique, individual way.

Read his full article here.

domain.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The Idle Ents
You’re part of this world, aren’t you? A tree-herder should know better! Last week I had the pleasure of participating in the First Kuyper Seminar, “Economics, Christianity & The Crisis: Towards a New Architectonic Critique,” held at the VU University Amsterdam. I gave a paper on “The Moral Challenges of Economic Equality and Diversity,” which focused on envy as a moral challenge particularly endemic to market economies: “Since envy arises out of inequality, envy and inequality go together. And since...
Commentary: Hollywood 2012: What Messages are the Movies Sending Us?
“If I had cash to spend on promoting the values and ideas and policies that I believed were best for this country, you can bet that I would be out finding talented directors, writers, and producers who shared those values,” writes R.J. Moeller. The full text of his essay follows. Subscribe to the free, weekly Acton News & Commentary and other publicationshere. Hollywood 2012: What messages are the movies sending us? byR.J. Moeller The list ofthe twenty-five top-grossing films(worldwide) of...
Audio: Samuel Gregg discusses ‘Becoming Europe’ in two new interviews
Samuel Gregg, director of research at the Acton Institute, recently had two interviews discussing his latest book, ing Europe. Here is his interview on the Armstrong & Getty Show: [audio: Here is his interview on the Dennis Miller Show: [audio: Lord Griffiths of Fforestfach, the vice chairman of Goldman Sachs International and former special adviser to Margaret Thatcher, said this about ing Europe: Highly readable, well researched, and extremely timely. This book is the definitive case why America should cling...
Access vs. Ownership in ‘Collaborative Consumption’
New rental markets are popping up all over the place, as detailed by a recent Wall Street Journal article. The trend is beginning to drive a larger movement labeled by some as “collaborative consumption,” wherein “sharing” is pushed as a way of “reinventing old market behaviors.” Over at Carpe Diem, Mark J. Perry provides a helpful round-up on the phenomenon, pointing to the already mentioned WSJ article, a new Collaborative Consumption Hub web site, and a host of relevant products...
Acton University: An Invigorating Intellectual Experience
Registration is now open for Acton University, planned for June 18-21, 2013. Courses for this year’s conference (subject to change) include Theology of Work, Social Entrepreneurship, Rise and Fall of the European Social Market, Fertility’s Impact on the World Economy, and Islam, Markets and the Free Society. (A full course listing can be seen here.) If you’re new to Acton, or would like to share the Acton University experience with someone, please enjoy Acton Institute Presents: Acton University. ...
Vatican II and Religious Liberty
Of all the documents that came out of the Catholic Church’s Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae (Declaration on Religious Liberty) was, says Omar F.A. Gutierrez, the most revised, debated, and controversial. But as Gutierrez argues, it also represented a development, rather than a reversal of Catholic teaching: The perception of the Church’s teaching by many was that whenever she found herself in the minority, the Church would cry religious liberty. However, if the Church was in the majority, the state...
Does the Work of Truck Drivers Matter to God?
Don’t believe the vocational lie, says Paul Rude, for God has imbued your mundane work with immense dignity and significance: The interview playing over my car radio was standard fare. The host of a Christian program was interviewing a wildly popular contemporary Christian music star—little more than background noise as I drove down the highway. But then the discussion landed on the topic of serving the Lord in ministry. The musician told the listening world how his brother was once...
How to Develop a Christian Mind in Business School (Part IV)
Note: This is the fourth in a series on developing a Christian mind in business school. You can find the intro and links to all previous posts here. As I mentioned in the last post, when in this series I talk about developing a Christian mind in b-school I’m referring primarily to learning how to think Christianly about things as they are symbolized, things as they are known, and things as they municated. That is, how to think Christianly about...
Samuel Gregg: ‘Becoming Europe’ – A Heritage Event
Author of ing Europe” and Acton’s Director or Research, Samuel Gregg, will be at The Heritage Foundation on Thursday, February 7 to speak on “Economic Decline, Culture, and How America Can Avoid a European Future.” The event can be attended in person or viewed online. Visit the Heritage events page for more details. Read an excerpt of ing Europe” and purchase the book here. ...
What is the Purpose of Our Government?
If we asked many of our fellow Americans today “What is the purpose of government?,” undoubtedly, we might be barraged with some vexing ical answers. But I’m not one to believe that a good deal of our citizens can’t answer this question quite intelligibly. Still, I don’t think it would be enough to embody a healthy republic. It is time for our country to ask these basic questions again. It seems as if the looming chaos of our current national...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved