Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Another Rolling Stone Ruse
Another Rolling Stone Ruse
Nov 30, 2025 2:02 PM

When es to addressing the latest hit-piece in Rolling Stone regarding the Acton Institute, Rev. Robert Sirico is front and center, top of the charts, so to speak. I’d like to take a whack at it, myself, if readers will indulge me.

“Pope Francis’ American Crusade” appears in the same magazine (in)famously trumpeting liberal causes for nearly 50 years, and the very same publication with a boss worth more than $700 million, earned primarily from a magazine that applauds the conspicuous lifestyles of thuggish actors and “musicians;” and the same magazine that has celebrated unabashed materialism while bashing capitalism since its inception. The very same magazine that could be accused of white, American capitalist imperialism for ripping off its very name from the titles of famous songs by Muddy Waters (a black man) and Bob Dylan (Jewish and Minnesotan) as well as a British rock group.

It seems the article’s author – one Mark Binelli – succumbs to the tried-and-true tactic employed by the magazine’s editorial contributors since time immemorial, which is to quote anyone regardless credibility or integrity if they support the Rolling Stone writer’s agenda. For example, famed scofflaw Rep. Charles Rangel is quoted: “People can distort the Bible any way they want to, but when you have science and religion on the same side of a question, there’s no place for fundamentalists to go. You speak against the pope at your own risk.” Apparently, according to Binelli, readers should consider Rangel a martyr because he “says he has had invitations to speak at Catholic high school graduations rescinded by local religious leaders, apparently because of his pro-choice views.”

Conversely, if someone disagrees with a Rolling Stone writer’s agenda, they are paraphrased in the service of juvenile mocking:

It’s been more fun watching the response of the Republican presidential nominees, six of whom happen to be Catholic and most of them far fortable talking about defunding Planned Parenthood or ginning up bogus “religious liberty” issues — the Supreme Court is going to force you to bake a gay wedding cake! — than addressing global warming. Rick Santorum, who has called climate change a hoax, advised the pope to leave “science to the scientists,” while Jeb Bush — who, as governor of Florida, ordered the reinsertion of a feeding tube of a woman in a persistent vegetative state, in explicit defiance of both her husband and the courts — told Sean Hannity, “I don’t get economic policy from my bishops or my cardinals or my pope. . . . I think religion ought to be about making us better as people and less about things that end up getting in the political realm.” Chris Christie, in a similar vein, attempted to demonstrate his independence from Rome with an ill-advised anecdote, sharing with voters at a New Hampshire restaurant that he has used birth control, “and not just the rhythm method!”

(Donald Trump, who is not Catholic, has yet to tweet about what a loser the pope is, but [National Catholic Reporter journalist Michael Sean] Winters thinks the pair make irresistible counterpoints: Francis’ rejection of many of the trappings of his office has “just blown up” the imperial atmosphere of the Vatican — “You don’t have a court if you don’t live in the palace, and it’s hard to maintain a courtly atmosphere if you’re waiting in line at the cafeteria” — while Trump “would have made a great 16th-century pontiff. When you go to Rome and see all of those baroque churches, what is written over their edifices? The names of the popes who built them. Those were the Trumps of their era!”)

Yawn. Binelli even takes a swipe at Michael Novak and George Weigel: “Self-styled papal translators like Weigel and Novak selected passages from often-dense speeches and encyclicals to support their theses. The same thing happened under Pope Benedict.” Seriously, this article is beginning to shape up as little more than what you’d expect to read in one of those mimeographed, underground “newspapers” you’d find in the local food co-op back in 1973 or so. Of course, asserts Binelli vis-à-vis Winters, if you disagree with Francis it’s evidence, naturally, of racism. Yes, the article actually goes there, because dislike of wealth redistribution must naturally derive from a deep-seated, dislike of Italian-born Argentineans. But here’s Winters:

You do hear attempts to manipulate and trim what he’s saying, with what I can only characterize as somewhat racist overtones: ‘Oh, the poor, benighted Argentine doesn’t understand how wonderful us Americans are.’…

And Binelli:

The near-impossibility bating such well-funded disinformation campaigns is a depressing reality for progressives. What has the right so jumpy about Francis is the size of his bully pulpit, which even unlimited spending might not be able to counter. Consider, for instance, the 24/7 global media coverage Francis’ U.S. trip will receive. When else would an economic message as critical of capitalism as Francis’ be granted such a stage?

It’s difficult believing Rolling Stone’s editors read either paragraph with a straight face. Yes, Pope Francis: Champion of circumventing Citizens United! Good grief.

Binelli cavils about evil corporations (pejoratively name checking ExxonMobil Corporation, for example) , capitalism and materialism, because, you know, the grave sin of accepting money from corporations apparently knows no equal in the Rolling Stone universe:

Deeply alarmed by the power of Francis’ message, an entire network of right-wing Catholic organizations has been increasingly willing to push back against the Vatican. Tim Busch, the chairman of the California-based Napa Institute — which holds an annual summer conference that draws Catholic business leaders — recently announced plans to help fund a $3 million research and education program at the Catholic University of America in Washington, D.C., “focused on patibility of capitalism and Catholicism.” (Other funders include the Charles Koch Foundation.)

Cue the John Williams’ Darth Vadar theme from Star Wars.

As I pour through the crates of Rolling Stone back issues I’ve collected since high school, I’m certainly not surprised the magazine and website are supported by advertisers and subscribers, which is fair enough, I suppose. I don’t begrudge publisher Jann Wenner his $700 million fortune despite the acres of dead trees sacrificed these past five decades to print his rag; the tremendous amount of oil to press the vinyl the magazine promoted and reviewed as its core function back in the day; the barrels more of fossil fuels used by Wenner and his staff to jet-set around the world just like the rock stars they covered; and the refined crude used for the ink to print “all the news that fits” – the Rolling Stone motto.

To paraphrase Bob Dylan, “How does it feel to make millions from your toil/using barrels of plete turmoil/ like ol’ Rolling Stone?”

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Ralph Raico on Religion, Lord Acton, and Classical Liberalism
One of the charges sometimes leveled against classical liberal thought is thatit opposes all authority; that it seeks toreduce society to an amalgamation of atomized individuals, eliminating the role of munity, and vibrant social institutions. Historian Ralph Raico seeks to argue the very opposite in his dissertation, The Place of Religion in the Liberal Philosophy of Constant, Tocqueville, and Lord Acton.The work has been republished for the first time by the Mises Institute. (A particularly interesting note is that the...
Health Care Subsidiarity in the UK and the US
A recent New York Times story reports that the new British government plans to “decentralize” the National Health Care system as part of its new austerity measures. Practical details of the plan are still sketchy. But its aim is clear: to shift control of England’s $160 billion annual health budget from a centralized bureaucracy to doctors at the local level. Under the plan, $100 billion to $125 billion a year would be meted out to general practitioners, who would use...
Salary and Significance
During a recent conversation, a Chinese friend of mented on the lack of political involvement that she has observed in her peers, especially parison to American college students. She attributes this lack of involvement to the fact that the Chinese do not believe that political action can change the policies or even the identities of their leaders. As a result, non-politicians in China do not get involved in politics, and politicians there focus on achieving their own goals rather than...
Europe’s Surviving Farmers Show True Entrepreneurial Spirit
Are the Old Continent’s farmers showing that they have a real entrepreneurial spirit and serving as role models of courage and innovation during the Great Recession? Surely not all of them, but there are some inspiring examples to be found in Central and Southern Europe. This is somewhat surprising as Europe’s agricultural sector is usually among the most traditional, least open to market innovation and product flexibility, and heavily reliant on EU funding to keep the petitive. Alas, European leadership...
Rome’s Graffiti and Bastiat’s Broken Windows
Today’s Wall Street Journal has a nice piece about the problem of graffiti in Rome and the obstacles to cleaning it all up. While the graffiti are certainly an eyesore in an otherwise beautiful city, there is also great economic damage done, which leads to impoverished understandings of private property and general urban decay. If cleaning up the graffiti on a four-story palazzo can cost as much as €40,000, there are surely people there to profit from the clean-up. And...
Chinese Politics: Power, Ideology, and the Limits of Pragmatism
Chinese Communism is no longer about ideology. Now it is about power. I reached this conclusion on the basis of six months spent in China and extensive conversations with my Chinese friend and fellow Acton intern Liping, whose analysis has helped me greatly in writing this post. China began moving away from Communist ideology under Deng Xiaoping, whose economic reforms munes and created space for private businesses. He justified these reforms to his Communist colleagues with the saying, “It doesn’t...
Re: Broken Windows – University Funding Edition
As Kishore Jayabalan noted yesterday, the fallacy of “broken windows” is, unfortunately, ubiquitous in discussions of public finance and macroeconomics. Though we are told that government spending and public works have a stimulating effect on economic activity, rarely are the costs of such projects discussed. Such is the case with several stimulus projects in my own hometown of Atlanta, GA. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reportson a list that Sen. John McCain and Sen. Tim Coburn drew up,criticizing wasteful stimulus projects throughout...
An Open Letter from Alexis de Tocqueville to President Barack Obama and the American People
I think that the oppression threatening democracies will not be like anything there has been in the world before…. I see an innumerable crowd of men, all alike and equal, turned in upon themselves in a restless search for those petty, vulgar pleasures with which they fill their souls…. Above these men stands an immense and protective power which alone is responsible for looking after their enjoyments and watching over their destiny. It is absolute, meticulous, ordered, provident, and kindly...
Manuel F. Ayau (1925-2010): A Life for Liberty, Justice, and the Truth
Those who love freedom were saddened to learn this morning of the passing of one of the most significant contributors to the cause of liberty and individual responsibility in Latin America, Manuel F. Ayau, affectionately known as “Muso” to his many friends and acquaintances, after a long and brave struggle with cancer. A humble, self-effacing but determined man, Ayau is a classic example of someone who made a difference. Whereas others confined themselves to talking about the free society, Ayau...
Here I Stand: Marketing and Remembering the Reformation
I just couldn’t pass this one up. Below is an ENI story on the installation of 800 “colourful miniature figures of the 16th-century Protestant Reformer Martin Luther” in the market square of Wittenberg. Just as last year there was a good deal of academic mercial interest around the 500th anniversary of the birth of John Calvin, you can expect a great deal of activity leading up to the 500th anniversary of the traditional date of the dawn of the Reformation...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved