Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
America’s meat industry needs more freedom, less federal control
America’s meat industry needs more freedom, less federal control
Jul 8, 2025 4:33 AM

Returning authority to the states for meat processing would bolster freedom, strengthen our political system, and spur more innovation across agriculture and enterprise.

Read More…

In the early 17th century, Calvinist philosopher Johannes Althusius put a distinctly Christian spin on earlier concepts of political subsidiarity. Althusius visualized civil bodies as not parts of a whole, but critical plete entities in themselves. Each body, or association, has a vocation to which it is divinely called, and each is meant to work together with other associations in symbiotic relationships.

Two hundred years later, Abraham Kuyper used the term “sphere sovereignty” to refer to the independence of each of these associations, and to the “limited and specific role” to which government has been assigned by God. To Kuyper, as well as Althusius, the role of the state was to protect the independence of each sphere, and to secure the contracts made between them.

Why does this distinction matter? Well, it strikes at the core of American politics.

Specifically, we see a vivid lack of subsidiarity in the meat processing industry, where mandates from the very top of government have suffocated ranchers and processors for decades.

In the name of “public safety” and “maintaining consumer confidence,” the government has created an artificial oligopoly in this industry, thereby creating intrinsic discrimination against small business. Ever since Congress passed the Wholesome Meat Act of 1967, under the Lyndon Johnson administration, all meat processing has been overseen by federal USDA guidelines. Certified inspectors must oversee every animal slaughtered, every slice of meat processed, and the finished cuts of meat themselves. Through the stringent HACCP regulations instituted in 1997, every meat processor must also create expensive safety plans for every single cut of meat.

The cost of these plans has been estimated at $13,540 per plan for small processors. Moreover, the original cost of bringing buildings up to new sanitation codes was a shocking $266,800 apiece. The safety issues of note are primarily those suffered by massive meat processors, while the price of pliance has been larger for the small plants.

The economic results of these costs has been an uppercut to munities, small meat processors, and consumers. Rural families surrounded by cows and pigs can’t purchase a pound of ground beef from their farming neighbor unless it was slaughtered at an officially inspected facility, which, as a side effect of regulation, often only accept bulk orders of animals from large farmers. Small meat processors have been forced out of business and the market has consolidated as a result, to the point where only four panies control 80% of the market.

Put simply, subsidiarity has been crushed in this industry, and it has had economy-wide ramifications.

We should remember that our nation is a constitutional republic, not a democracy, and that in itself is a check on majority rule laid by our founders. Further, a key political principle of subsidiarity is built into the U.S. Constitution in the Tenth Amendment, which guarantees a broad swath of rights to states as protections from federal tyranny.

In Federalist Paper 45, James Madison elaborated on the need for this amendment. “The powers reserved to the several States,” he writes, “will extend to all the objects which, in the ordinary course of affairs, concern the lives, liberties, and properties of the people, and the internal order, improvement, and prosperity of the State.”

Moreover, this ideal of a limited federal government was not some short-term concession to arrogant state delegations in the 1780s. Neither was the federal government given all authority over health issues, such as meat-borne pathogens. The reservation of powers to the states was a direct philosophical descendant of Christian subsidiarity, and it was included in the Constitution to ensure efficient and just politics. One recent paper outlines four main advantages of allowing most lawmaking to occur at the state level:

Regional variation in preferencesCompetition for taxpayers and businessesExperimentation to develop the best set of rulesLower monitoring costs

Thankfully, when es to the meat processing industry, all political hope is not lost. A bipartisan coalition has emerged, spearheaded by Congressmen and Senators from Kentucky and Maine that have worked together to sponsor the Processing Revival and Intrastate Meat Exemption (PRIME) Act in each of the last four Congresses. The PRIME Act would return jurisdiction over meat destined for in-state sale to the state itself.

All four benefits of state governance listed above e to pass under the PRIME Act. States could develop the best codes for their regions, tailored to each level of processor size. Competition would certainly increase, as small ranchers and processors alike would get more opportunity to sell their goods. Instead of a stagnant, national set of rules, states could foster creativity and innovation in policy to figure out the best balance between consumer safety and economic freedom. With more innovative rules would e a lessening of burdensome regulations, allowing cheaper costs across the board for meat.

The PRIME Act might not be a panacea, but it would be a major boost of freedom for our political system, the economies of rural America, and every consumer who cares about their meat.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Disaster Response and the Ministry of Presence
I wrote a piece on the Church’s response to disaster relief in the Spring issue of Religion & Liberty. The article for R&L is in part an extension of mentary “Out of the Whirlwind: God’s Love and Christian Charity” after a tornado hit Joplin, Mo. in May. Being a Katrina evacuee myself, I returned to the Mississippi Gulf Coast for a time after seminary and the devastation of so many things I was familiar with and had known was simply...
Otto von Habsburg (1912-2011)
I cannot permit the death of His Imperial and Royal Highness Otto von Habsburg at age 98 on July 4th to pass unnoticed. To look into his face was to gaze into the map of the 20th Century, and to hear him recount his ideas, insights and encounters was worth more than an entire course in European history in most universities. Only slightly acquainted with the man (his father Emperor Karl was beatified by Pope John Paul II in 2004),...
Questions for Ethanol
Political news changes quickly, and now reports ing out of Washington DC that Senator Dianne Feinstein, who has been leading the way in killing the ethanol subsidy and tariff, has struck a deal with Senators Amy Klobuchar and John Thune, two stalwarts for protecting ethanol. While the rumored deal does not indicate the repeal of the blending mandate it is a step in the right direction. However, while we wait on Congress and the President for action, the Brazilian ethanol...
Pope Benedict and Liturgical Beauty
There has been a lot of buzz throughout the Roman Catholic Church as it prepares to implement a new missal on November 27. As the Church begins a new chapter in its history, Tony Oleck writes an article for Crisis Magazine titled “The True Beauty of Liturgy.” Oleck is a Roman Catholic seminarian for the Congregation of Holy Cross and a summer intern at the Acton Institute. In his article Oleck explains the reasoning behind Pope Benedict’s new missal while...
Editorial: Intergenerational Ethics and Economics
My editorial, “Intergenerational Ethics and Economics,” appears in the latest issue of the Journal of Markets & Morality (more details about that issue here). In this short piece I explore some of the implications and intergenerational consequences of public debt. For this I take my point of departure with the much-discussed “A Call for Intergenerational Justice,” but I also point out the importance of considering opportunity cost and how that concept has been applied in an analogous conversation about climate...
Space and “the primal desire to conquer”
Space shuttle Atlantis lifts off the launch pad for the final space shuttle mission. Image credit: NASA TVImagine you’re eight and you’re given a dog. The first thing your parents say is that you need to take care of him: feed him, play with him in the backyard, and train him so that he doesn’t do bad things in the house. You and the new dog quickly e “the dog and his master.” That well-worn phrase can tell us something...
Relief Efforts Stall Out in Haiti
Acton’s Rev. Robert A. Sirico published an article in Religion and Liberty in the fall of 2010 on Haiti and how we could help it recover. It has been several months since then, and eighteen months since a 7.0 magnitude earthquake struck Haiti near Port-au-Prince, killing around 230,000 people. Eighteen months is a long time and many, including myself, have pushed Haiti into the background of their minds. However, Haiti is still desperately struggling to recover from this terrible disaster....
Journal of Markets & Morality 14, no. 1 (Spring 2011)
The newest edition of the Journal of Markets & Morality is now available online to subscribers. This issue of the journal features a Scholia translation of selections from On the Observation of the Mosaic Polity by Franciscus Junius (1545-1602), the Huguenot, Reformed, scholastic theologian (a Latin version of Junius’ original treatise is available for download at Google Books, along with a host of his other works). Best known as a professor of theology at Leiden University from 1592–1602, Junius authored...
Water: A Right or a Commodity?
Water is ing scarcer and even more of a necessity than it was before. And while stories of water scarcity typically occur in underdeveloped, arid countries, the United States and other developed countries must realize they are no longer exceptions and must take into consideration the importance of water and the allocation of its use. A recent article in the Wall Street Journal explores the severe lack of water in Palm Beach, Florida. Residents are restricted to once-a-week watering schedules...
Real Healthcare Reform
Many politicians have talked of repealing the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (“Obamacare”). Mitt Romney has said nullifying the healthcare law would be one of his first actions if he was elected president. However, rather than just repealing the law and going back to the status-quo, with minor changes, the American people should demand true reform. In 2001, Milton Friedman, the famed, Nobel-prize winning economist, published an article titled “How to Cure Health Care.” (Although worthy of serious consideration,...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved