Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Amazon’s HQ2: Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is right, and wrong
Amazon’s HQ2: Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is right, and wrong
Apr 26, 2025 12:27 AM

After much anticipation, Amazon announced yesterday that it will open its new headquarters, HQ2, in two locations: Queens, New York, and Crystal City, Virginia. It will also open a third “Operations Center of Excellence” in Nashville. Controversy attended the announcement, as all three cities promised pany subsidies and tax incentives topping $2.2 billion.

New York pledged $1.525 billion between tax incentives and grants. Virginia and Arlington agreed to an $800 million package, more than half-a-billion of it in cash grants. Nashville offered up to $102 million in tax credits and grants, many of them conditional.

These peted with 238 cities across the continent for the center, and its jobs. The average incentive package of the 20 semi-finalists totaled “$2.15 billion from cities and $6.75 billion from states over the next 15 years,” according to Michael Farren and Anne Philpot of the Mercatus Center. Some locations offered as much as $8 billion to lure Amazon.

After the announcement, the newly elected Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-Queens, tweeted:

Amazon is a pany. The idea that it will receive hundreds of millions of dollars in tax breaks at a time when our subway is crumbling and munities need MORE investment, not less, is extremely concerning to residents here.

— Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@Ocasio2018) November 13, 2018

Her objections are partly right and partly wrong.

She is right: Businesses don’t need these incentives.

Amazon is actually a pany, albeit one with a low profit margin. That makes these giveaways even less defensible.

What’s more, although Amazon told cities that “tax structure” would be a “high-priority” consideration, politicians’ giveaways don’t necessarily change pany’s decision. CEOs look for a skilled workforce, transportation, aligned industries, and, yes, a business-friendly environment. “Tax incentives and tax packages are uniformly viewed as low priorities … relatively unimportant to the basic decision,” according to Natalie Cohen of the Brookings Institution. One researcher found that as many as 90 percent of businesses would have invested in Texas without any state subsidy. These grants squander taxpayers’ money with little or no effect on the e.

She is right: This is cronyism.

Citizens should be concerned that politicians are giving away taxpayers’ funds to a well-connected corporation, so it can locate near the locus of political power. “Economic development” grants favor huge corporations. A 2014 study found that legislators handing out incentives are “biased toward panies.”

Picking winners and losers in the economy keeps politicians from treating all businesses – and all their constituents – equally. The cities and states that vied for Amazon’s HQ2 could have reduced their corporate e taxes by an average of 29 percent across-the-board, Farren and Philpot found. “Colorado, Maryland, and North Carolina could all cut their corporate e taxes by over 70 percent.” Instead of giving all businesses a break, corporation-specific tax incentives distort the market and give some employers an unfair advantage over their actual, or petitors.

“These tax breaks are wrong. Dead wrong,” wrote Veronique de Rugy of Mercatus in National Review. “And your repeating until you are red in the face that they are great because pany will create jobs will not make these breaks ethically or economically acceptable.”

She is (partly) right: (Some of) this money could be spent on other things.

“If we have $1.7b to give to Amazon, then that means we have $1.7b to forgive NY student loan debt,” Cortez tweeted. One can quibble over what should be funded, but government spending es with an opportunity cost. Washington, D.C., could have increased its police force by 181 percent. New York state could have paid for all of its road maintenance, statewide, for three years.

There’s another option, seemingly unthinkable to any politician: The government could have refrained from spending the money at all.

However, reducing or eliminating taxes is not “spending.” Tax cuts allow an individual or business to keep more of the money they have earned. If the jobs generate more aggregate economic activity, the budget does not shrink.

She is wrong: Economic development benefits munity.

Although Amazon may have created these jobs in Cortez’s district without the incentives, there will be jobs: The promised jobs will benefit an estimated 25,000 of her constituents with a salary of at least $100,000, a promise of $2.5 billion in Amazon investment. (The same figures apply to D.C.) Amazon promises Nashville another 5,000 full-time jobs and $230 million in investment. This does not include economic activity generated by those employees’ consumption. Cortez portrays this as the “displacement” of the indigenous poor. However, living in greater proximity to wealth benefits the poor, including those who do not receive one of the 25,000 new jobs.

She is wrong: The jobs will be good for her constituents.

Work allows an individual to “make legitimate use of his talents to contribute to the abundance that will benefit all and to harvest the just fruits of his labor,” according to the Catechism of the Catholic Church. Aside from the financial impact, the jobs benefit employees spiritually by allowing them to develop their latent abilities. “Work honors the Creator’s gifts and the talents received from Him,” providing a forum in which the person “exercises and fulfills” the “potential inscribed in his nature.”

However, that person may have found just as fruitful labor with another employer, or without extravagant crony packages bribing Amazon to move into the neighborhood.

Webster. This photo has been cropped. CC BY-SA 2.0.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
How to Steal a Bike in New York City
Edmund Burke didn’t really say it, but it still rings true: All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing. In a test of this maxim, filmmaker Casey Neistat tries to steal his own bike in several locations around New York City and finds that most people do nothing about it—even when it’s done right in front of a police station. I recently spent a couple of days conducting a bike theft experiment, which...
How to Love Liberty More Than a Libertarian Economist
I have a deep and abiding love for liberty—which is why I find myself so often in disagreement with libertarians. Libertarians love liberty too, of course, but they tend to love liberty a bit differently. I love liberty in an earthy, elemental way. I love liberty because I need it—like I need air and food—for human flourishing. In contrast, the libertarians I’ve encountered tend to love liberty primarily as an abstraction. Indeed, the most ideologically consistent libertarians I know seem...
Is Work a Curse?
Is work a curse, a result of mankind’s fall from grace? Not according to the Book of Genesis. As Hugh Whelchel, Executive Director of the Institute for Faith, Work & Economics, explains, what Adam was called to do in the garden is what we are still called to do in our work today: Humanity was created by God to cultivate and keep God’s creation, which included developing it and protecting it. You see, we were created to be stewards of...
Italy’s Tax Man Takes Aim at the Vatican
Kishore Jayabalan, the Acton Institute’s Rome office director, was interviewed by the Zenit news agency in an article titled, “Is Taxing the Church a Real Solution for Italy?” In the article, Jayabalan discusses the history of the Italian state and its imposition of property taxes on the Roman Catholic Church’s land holdings, residences and non-profit businesses. Sometimes in the past, particularly under Napoleonic rule and before the Lateran Pacts, the institution of property tax was often a subject of state...
Constitutional Cases and the Four Cardinal Virtues
Should virtue be a consideration in judicial decisionmaking? Indiana Law Professor R. George Wright makes an intriguing argument for why the four cardinal virtues could be useful in interpreting constitutional cases: Judges typically decide constitutional cases by referring to one or more legal precedents, rules, tests, principles, doctrines, or policies. This Article mends supplementing this standard approach with fully legitimate and appropriate attention to what many cultures have long recognized as the four basic cardinal virtues of practical wisdom or...
Obamacare’s Religious Rubes
The White House has a plan to mobilize prayer vigils in front of the Supreme Court in defense of Obamacare. It was reported that the administration met with leaders at non-profit organizations and religious officials who support the new health care law. The court takes up the constitutional test of the health care mandate in a couple of weeks. The mandate has now been challenged in 26 states. Cue the same stale big government religious prophets who confuse statism and...
Reagan, Whittaker Chambers, and the Threat to Freedom
Over at the Liberty Law Blog, there is an excellent post titled “Ronald Reagan, Whittaker Chambers, and the Dialogue of Liberty” by Alan Snyder. Snyder delves into the influence Chambers had on Reagan and how their worldviews differed as well. Many conservatives and scholars felt Chambers’ prediction that the West was on the losing side of history in the battle against Marxism collapsed after the fall of the Iron Curtain and the Soviet Union. For many, the ideas of Chambers...
Let’s Change Hearts and Minds (and Laws, Too)
Few clichés are so widespread within the evangelical subculture, says Matthew Lee Anderson, as the notion that our witness must be one of “changing hearts and minds.” In careful hands, the idea is at best ambiguous. At worst it reinforces the sort of interior-oriented individualism that allows for and perpetuates a blissful naivete about how institutions and structures shape our dispositions and thoughts. In less than careful hands, the phrase drives a wedge between law and culture by attempting to...
Integral Human Development
The Journal of Markets & Morality is planning a theme issue for the Spring of 2013: “Integral Human Development,” i.e. the synthesis of human freedom and responsibility necessary for the material and spiritual enrichment of human life. According to Pope Benedict XVI, Integral human development presupposes the responsible freedom of the individual and of peoples: no structure can guarantee this development over and above human responsibility. (Caritas in Veritate 17) There is a delicate balance between the material and the...
Lord Acton and the Power of the Historian
Looking through my back stacks of periodicals the other day I ran across a review in Books & Culture by David Bebbington, “Macaulay in the Dock,” of a recent biography of Thomas Babington Macaulay. The essay takes its point of departure in Lord Acton’s characterization of Macaulay as “one of the greatest of all writers and masters, although I think him utterly base, contemptible and odious.” As Bebbington writes, “Acton, a towering intellectual of the later 19th century, was at...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved