Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Acton Commentary: Obama Administration Leaves Human Trafficking Victims Out in the Cold
Acton Commentary: Obama Administration Leaves Human Trafficking Victims Out in the Cold
Jan 24, 2026 11:58 PM

“Most of us enjoy an economy where we can purchase with ease the things we need and enjoy. However, there is no moral justification for mercialization of some things; human beings are not products to be bought and sold,”writes Elise Hiltonin the latest Acton Commentary (published October 3).The full text of his essay follows. Subscribe to the free, weekly Acton News & Commentary and other publicationshere.

Obama Administration Leaves Human Trafficking Victims Out in the Cold

By Elise Hilton

Imagine a teen girl: After a fight with her mom, she takes off. It happens a lot; maybe her mom drinks too much. The teenager’s winter afternoon walk leads nowhere in particular, until a man in a car stops. He asks if he can buy her something warm to drink, telling her she is too pretty to be out alone on a cold day. pliment is enough to get her in the car. She’s just e a trafficked person, snared into the sex trade.

Child or human trafficking is one of the fastest growing crimes in the world. The Department of Justice notes the average age of a child for entry into the sex trade is 12, and 300,000 American children are at risk annually for this crime.

Most of us enjoy an economy where we can purchase with ease the things we need and enjoy. However, there is no moral justification for mercialization of some things; human beings are not products to be bought and sold.

On September 25, President Obama launched a $6 million effort aimed at trafficking. “When a little girl is sold by her impoverished family — girls my daughters’ age — runs away from home, or is lured by the false promises of a better life, and then imprisoned in a brothel and tortured if she resists — that’s slavery,” he said. “It is barbaric, and it is evil, and it has no place in a civilized world.” He praised faith-based organizations bat trafficking.

There is a sick irony to this. Last year, the associate director for anti-trafficking services at the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops’ (USCCB) program, Hilary Chester, said her staff hoped that a strong record of aiding trafficked victims would keep federal funds flowing into the program. That was before the USCCB received an email stating that it would no longer receive government funds because the Catholic Church refuses to provide abortion, sterilization and artificial birth control to its employees or those the Church’s agencies serve.

The highly-regarded USCCB-administered program coordinated a network of organizations, many faith-based, overseeing $15 million in government funds, according to the National Catholic Register. Now, that money is gone. Maricella Garcia, of Catholic Charities in Little Rock, Ark., says her agency has stopped offering services to trafficked victims. “The grant that the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops had is that they provided direct assistance money,” she said. “That could help a victim pay for rent or help them pay for food. We don’t have that capability anymore.”

This is more than a bureaucratic decision to fund one agency over another. The Obama Administration is waging war against religious liberty, the HHS mandate its biggest gun. The mandate states that group health plans must cover “[FDA-]approved contraceptive methods, sterilization procedures, and patient education and counseling for all women with reproductive capacity. FDA approved contraception includes Plan B (morning after pill).” Organizations with moral objections to these procedures and medications face stiff financial penalties for pliance.

To date, more than 80 plaintiffs have filed suit against the mandate, not all Catholic. David Green, founder of the craft-store chain Hobby Lobby, joined the lawsuit, citing his evangelical Christian faith: “We simply cannot abandon our religious beliefs ply with this mandate.” Sixty-five Eastern Orthodox bishops have called for the rescinding of this mandate. Michael Milton, chancellor of Reformed Theological Seminary in North Carolina stated, “This is not a Catholic issue only. It is not a contraception issue. It is a religious liberty issue.”

Back to our teenage girl. Say she manages to escape a life that included beatings, starvation, imprisonment and prostitution. She will need counseling, a place to live, an education, means to support herself. Where can she turn? According to Obama’s new initiative, she can turn to a business-to-business network established to identify trafficking, or a research partnership at a university. Perhaps she’ll find help from the tourism industry where an awareness campaign has been promoted.

That’s absurd. The girl won’t find help from these places. The help she needs was to be found in the thousands of local and state agencies previously funded — now with nothing to offer. For many religious groups, there will be no more governmental funds to counsel her, help her get a GED, an apartment or put food in the cupboard. The Obama Administration has decided that above and beyond this care, there must be provisions for abortions, sterilization and artificial birth control. Although these agencies are closest to the problem, know the situation in their area, and are most familiar with how to help someone there, the HHS mandate says they can’t help at all, if they don’t offer services they find morally reprehensible. Unless the munity and private donors are able to fill in the substantial financial gap, most of these agencies that previously served trafficking victims will find themselves unable to offer help.

Where does that leave the girl? Just as vulnerable as she was before, walking down the street after a fight with her mother.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Why are Churches Singled Out for Their Tax-Exempt Status?
Guidelines for nonprofits are often misunderstood, says Dimitri Cavalli, and they are sometimes misrepresented by those seeking to quiet churches: Every so often, there are calls for the federal government to revoke the tax-exempt status of churches. The mon arguments made for taxing churches are that exemptionsdeny the government important sources of revenueto pay its bills, and that many churches (usually the ones that continue to teach traditional sexuality morality such as the Catholic, Evangelical, and Mormon churches) oftenabuse their...
Why State Governments Should Issue Lottery Tickets to People on Welfare
In a prime example of how irony is lost on politicians, lawmakers in North Carolina are proposing to prohibit people receiving welfare from playing in the lottery. Perhaps the legislators aren’t aware of what state lotteries are, in effect if not intent, designed to do: redistribute the e of mostly poor Americans to a handful of other citizens—and to the state’s coffers. Nevertheless, the lawmaker’s moral intuitions seem to be leading them to good intentions. As Rep. Paul Stam says,...
Why Should We Work?
Why do we go to work, day after day, year after year for most of our lives? Sure, we most of us have to “make a living?” But is that our only motivation? Is there a better reason why we should work? Matthew Kaemingk thinks so: Aboveeach of thesepartial reasons for work, I would like to propose an alternative motivation that should qualify, define, limit, and rule them all. This reason is simple but not narrow. It is focused on...
Necessity as the Mother of Innovation
There’s an old proverb, “Necessity is the mother of invention.” Life is often difficult, full of challenges, trials, and travails. But it is a testament to the human spirit, created in the image of God to mature and develop morally, spiritually, and intellectually, that in the face of such troubles human ingenuity often wins out. Brad Morgan, a dairy farmer turned fertilizer magnate featured in the documentary The Call of the Entrepreneur, put it this way: “You put your butt...
NAACP, Hispanics Fight Government Intervention
Last September the New York City Board of Health approved a measure that would ban the sale of sugary drinks over 16 ounces. Politicians justified the action because of the city’s escalating obesity rate and research linking sugary drinks to weight gain. Overall, care for obesity-related illnesses costs the New York City nearly $2.8 billion annually, according to city Health Commissioner Dr. Thomas Farley. Politicians, then, believe they have the authority to legislate how much of a beverage citizens can...
U.S. Catholic Bishops Find New Ways to Fight Human Trafficking
In 2011, the Obama administration cut off funding to the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) that was used to fight human trafficking. The USCCB lost funding for its refusal to provide abortions, sterilizations and artificial birth control in their anti-trafficking programs, as these services are all immoral, according to Catholic teaching. Now, the bishops have re-grouped, and are launching a new initiative in the fight against human trafficking. The USCCB’s new educational campaign, The Amistad Movement, rolls out this...
Questioning Obama’s Hand On The Bible
Just after the Presidential inauguration several leaders raised questions about whether or not President Obama should have sworn the oath of office by placing his hand on the Bible. Mark Driscoll, pastor of Mars Hill Church—a Protestant mega-church in Seattle—after seeing Obama sworn in said, “Praying for our president, who today will place his hand on a Bible he does not believe to take an oath to a God he likely does not know.” ments stirred up a firestorm of...
The FAQs: School Choice
In honor of the third annual National School Choice Week, here are some facts you should know about school choice in America. What does “school choice” mean? The term “school choice” refers to programs that give parents the power and opportunity to choose the schools their children attend, whether public, private, parochial, or homeschool. Why is school choice necessary? While there are some excellent public schools in America, many students are trapped in schools with inadequate facilities, substandard curriculum, and...
Free Market Judaism
“Judaism loves the market economy,” says Jonathan Sacks, Chief Rabbi for the British Orthodox synagogues. Rabbi Sacks explains how the “beautiful idea” parative advantage promotes peace, cooperation and tolerance among all people. (Via: Chris Robertson) ...
Jim Wallis, Davos Capitalism, Cronyism, and the ‘New Social Covenant’
Sojourners’ Jim Wallis has been at the Davos gathering in Switzerland and is urging us to be guided by a new Davos “covenant.” If you’ve never heard of Davos, Michael Miller’s RealClear Politics piece “Davos Capitalism” describes the gathering and its unassailable hubris this way: Davos capitalism, a managerial capitalism run by an enlightened elite–politicians, business leaders, technology gurus, bureaucrats, academics, and celebrities–all gathered together trying to make the economic world smarter or more humane…. And we looked up to...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved