Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
A victory for socialism? The Israeli Kibbutz
A victory for socialism? The Israeli Kibbutz
Apr 4, 2025 4:39 PM

While eating lunch at an Israeli Kibbutz last winter, I learned firsthand about what used to be a self-contained, munity. I was struck by the local guide’s positive view of socialism, believing it to produce munal life and economic prosperity. The guide’s praise only echoes A.I. Rabin and Benjamin Beit-Hallahmi from Michigan State University who wrote that “[t]he most successful attempt at building a mune has been the Israeli Kibbutz.” The optimism expressed by these observations is not without cause – the kibbutz movement was foundational to the establishment and success of the Israeli state.

“Kibbutz” refers to munities in Israel that were historically characterized by collective ownership of property, an emphasis on the dignity of manual labor, a system of direct democracy munal child care. In other words, no member exercised personal property rights but instead received toiletries, food and other necessities according to a distribution system. All members earned the same allowance for their work – regardless of whether their occupation consisted of milking cows, preparing meals or managing a large production facility. Children did not live in their family homes but instead grew up munal, child-rearing facilities. Marx would have smiled in his grave if he knew munal goods and services were provided “from each according to his or her ability, to each according to his or her needs.” Although most of the kibbutzim privatized in recent years, the appeal of its socialist ideology lives on; in fact, Senator Bernie Sanders himself lived and volunteered on a kibbutz in 1963 and is now a self-described democratic socialist.

Before Israel’s independence, the kibbutz provided structure for the defense of Jewish settlers and was the backbone of the rural economy. After Israel’s independence, the kibbutz supplied around twenty-percent of the country’s top military officers. Five prime ministers of Israel – David Ben-Gurion, Levi Eshkol, Golda Meir, Shimon Peres and Ehud Barak – were all at some point members of a kibbutz. In terms of members’ satisfaction, life expectancy, economic performance and demographic growth, the kibbutz society was “relative to the rest of society in Israel – very successful” until the nineties. These observations have led academics to ask whether the Israeli kibbutz sets itself apart from the myriad of failed socialist societies as a proven paragon of success.

Democratic socialists today like Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez believe that socialism is the key to poverty alleviation, and a rising number of young Americans are attracted to socialism as a moral economic system necessary to meet basic human needs. A YouGov survey revealed that 43% of respondents under age thirty had a favorable view of socialism. When asked what socialism is, millennials use phrases such as “nice”, “being together” or “the government pays for our needs.” Perhaps the success of the Israeli kibbutz is finally a victory for socialism. munal ideology propelled widespread killing and poverty in the Soviet Union, China, Vietnam, North Korea and Cambodia, the socialist values of the kibbutz society seemed to engender security, harmony and even prosperity.

But eventually the kibbutz would join the list of socialist models that were ultimately not ideologically sustainable. Debt and economic crisis were in part responsible for the abandonment of munalism. Mid-1980s Israel experienced a dire economic crisis with a 400 percent inflation rate and high levels of unemployment. Although the government and banks later on agreed to bailouts, the economic situation still disheartened many members of the kibbutz. In particular, the elderly worried if the kibbutz failed to provide for them again in the future, their lack of personal pensions would be problematic. The uncertainty and feelings of vulnerability sewn by the financial crisis incentivized individuals to build personal saving accounts rather than deposit all revenue munal funds.

Economic crisis was not the only culprit for munal values; quite the opposite phenomenon – a rise in industrialization and opportunity for higher standard of living – were additional blows to the sustainability of the kibbutz. Russell Raymond et al. write in their book The Renewal of the Kibbutz: From Reform to Transformation that “[i]n the first years of the kibbutzim, kibbutz members had little to share with each other but their poverty. The kibbutzniks’ self-denying, ascetic values were well suited to the economic condition of the kibbutzim.” munal ownership of housing, means of production and cafeterias was feasible – even attractive – when members were themselves impoverished, the pull munity weakened with an increase in the standard of living and availability of resources. The challenge of increased standards of living munal life is illustrated by the fact that more children moved to live with their parents as standard houses grew in size. Kibbutzim traditionally decried “the close knit family a creation of capitalism,” but eventually munities had to bow to the demands of children and parents. The new living situation led to increased privatization and individualization, munal cafeterias were less used and home-cooked meals became an accepted norm.

The popularity of the kibbutz in Israel is peculiar to me, given that Judaism emphasizes the importance of the nuclear family. Parents have a sacred obligation to care for and raise their children in Jewish tradition; children manded to respect their parents. Kibbutzim challenged the nuclear household, separating children from their parents. But families eventually united under one roof. Kibbutzim traditionally proportioned goods to members according to their needs regardless of their skill, but individuals eventually requested market-based wages. Members of kibbutzim were willing to equally share poverty, but when the individuals experienced prosperity from industrializing, inequality ensued. Ultimately, the story of the kibbutz highlights the crucial problem of socialism: its core tenants are at odds not only with Judeo-Christian principles but also with innate human tendencies to raise a pete in the workplace and make self-interested decisions.

Featured Image: Government Press Office (Israel) [CC BY-SA 3.0]

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The Root of All Freedoms: Kuyper on Freedom of Conscience
The Obama administration’s HHS mandate has led to significant backlash among religious groups, each claiming that certain provisions violate their religious beliefs and freedom of conscience. Yesterday’s Supreme Court rulingwas a victory for such groups, but other disputes are well underway, with many more e. Even among many of our fellow Christians, we see a concerted effort to chase religious belief out of the public square, confining such matters to Sunday mornings, where they can be kept behind closed doors....
Political Contributions To The Real War On Women
Gender disparity in pay has been discussed ad nauseum, especially given that the facts are that women really don’t get paid less than men, taking into account real life circumstances. But are there factors that hold women back? Women still tend to choose lower-paying jobs, and are more likely to leave the job market than men. Less than 5 percent of our nation’s leading CEOs and corporate leaders are female. What’s behind this? Abby M. McCloskey, program director of economic...
American Freedom: Is It Overrated?
We Americans will celebrate 238 years of freedom this Friday. In 1776, the 13 colonies unanimously declared: When in the Course of human events, it es necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare...
Net Neutrality and Religious Advocacy
Yesterday, Senator Patrick Leahy (D-VT) held a Senate hearing on his proposed bill, the Online Competition and Consumer Choice Act of 2014. The bill, reading at just four pages, serves as a tool bat “paid prioritization” in the network traffic business in an effort to maintain petition in that market. This idea, known as net neutrality, as explained by Joe Carter, assumes “that a public information network should aspire to treat all content, sites, and platforms equally” as well as...
China’s One-Child Policy Creates Human Trafficking Plights
China’s one-child policy and a cultural preference for boys means that the world’s most populous country has a severe shortage of women. That means a severe shortage of brides. And that means a human trafficking crisis. Kiab, a Vietnamese girl who had just turned 16, was told by her brother that he was taking her to a party. Instead, he sold her as a bride to a Chinese man. The ethnic Hmong teenager spent nearly a month in China until...
What You Need To Know About ISIL In Iraq
has an excellent piece on Iraq’s ISIL and the political crisis there. Here are some of the most salient points. ISIL is Al Qaeda’s arm in Syria and Iraq.ISIL began as ISI or “Islamic State in Iraq” and was seeking to regain power for Sunni Muslims. “…“…after U.S. forces left in 2011 the Iraqi government failed to follow U.S. advice to take good care of the Sunni tribes, if only to keep the tribes from again supporting the Islamic terrorist...
Audio & Video: Sirico on the Hobby Lobby Decision
Acton Institute President and Co-Founder Rev. Robert A. Sirico had a busy media day yesterday in the wake of the release of the Supreme Court’s decision in the Hobby Lobby vs. Sebelius case. using the audio player below, you can listen to an interview with Rev. Sirico on The Michael Berry Show on Houston’s 740 AM KTRH radio where the impact of the decision is examined. Additionally, beyond the jump I’ve embedded Rev. Sirico’s appearance on Bloomberg TV’sStreet Smart with...
Helping The Poor With, Of All Things, Cash
Christopher Blattman, an associate professor at Columbia’s School of International and Public Affairs, thinks giving cash to the poor is a good idea. Not free meals, not tickets to redeem for food, but cash. And it just might work. Blattman writes in The New York Times of the experience of giving cash to the poor. The knee-jerk reaction to this idea is, “Well, they’re just gonna waste it.” But Blattman finds evidence to the contrary. Globally, cash is a major...
Christ Plays in Ten Thousand Places
In the latest video blog fromFor the Life of the World, Evan Koons reads abeautiful poem by Gerard Manley Hopkins over some striking visual imagery. Watch it below: Hopkins begins by highlighting the wondrous and mysterious pulse of nature, moving eventually to the acts of we “mortal things,” prone to appease the self, and bent on crying, “Whát I dó is me: for that I came.” But he doesn’t stop here, for surely man was neither created nor destined to...
Hobby Lobby Reaction Speaks to Future of Religious Liberty
Regarding the Hobby Lobby decision and the Supreme Court, I believe the National Review editors summed it up best: “That this increase in freedom makes some people so very upset tells us more about them than about the Court’s ruling.” I address this rapid politicization and misunderstanding of religious liberty and natural rights in today’s mentary. The vitriolic reaction to the ruling is obviously not a good sign for religious liberty and we’re almost certainly going to continue down the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved