Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
A silver lining in the Golden State’s school shutdowns
A silver lining in the Golden State’s school shutdowns
Jan 13, 2026 12:17 PM

What happens in California doesn’t tend to stay in California – and that’s usually bad for America. For instance, “55% of all public school students, including those in charter schools, were at home, in distance learning, as of April 30, according to an EdSource analysis of new data released by the state.” However, a new and growing parental rights movement in the state is making headlines, creating change, and forging a national push for the nation’s still-shuttered schools to reopen over union opposition.

During the early stages of the reopening, opposition to lockdowns and shutdown due to COVID-19 were almost exclusively associated with Republican-leaning states. But even though California’s parents want to distance themselves from reflexive opposition to school closures, they are also demanding that teachers’ unions and their political officials stop opposing the science which shows that schools can safely reopen.

Their pleas have often been met with contempt. An entire district school board was forced to resign after a leaked recording showed board members insulting parents during a meeting. One member told critical parents, “I’m gonna f— you up!” The board president then suggested that parents “want to pick on us, because they want their babysitters back.” The head of a local teachers’ union was caught sending his daughter to a private preschool, even while he fought against reopening public schools. And a school board member in San Diego County claimed that setting a timeline for reopening schools was “a very white supremacist ideology” paring reopening requirements to “slavery.”

In the meantime, California’s parents are paying the taxes which fund $6.6 billion in extra funding for in-school instruction – which, again, the scientific evidence suggests should have started a long time ago.

As the Acton Institute has already reported, it’s quite clear that opponents of reopening schools have run out of excuses and are merely doing the politically expedient bidding of catering to teachers’ unions. The center-left Brookings Institution found that “politics, far more than science, shaped school district decision-making.” In fact, Brookings confirmed that “there is no relationship” between reopening decisions and COVID-19 cases.

The connection between school closings and children’s well-being is clear: Keeping kids home does little to reduce their likelihood of catching COVID-19, but extended shutdowns can cause or exacerbate mental health issues among young people.

California’s parents have had enough, and they’ve been voicing their anger to Gov. Gavin Newsom and other state officials. But it’s not clear that state officials are willing to put their foot down and get kids back to school. The law that includes the $6.6 billion handout to the school system did not actually require school districts to resume in-person instruction. It also did not specify how many days a week students must be in the classroom for schools to receive this extra funding; they could easily “reopen” for just one or two days a week, keeping students at home and glued to their screens the rest of the time, an qualify. At least one district adopted this half-measure.

The National Education Association is the nation’s largest union, and it is one of two powerful teachers’ unions. However, it looks like union officials have overplayed their hand in California: Even dependably liberal voters are starting to realize that teachers’ unions do not necessarily have their children’s interests in mind. This could provoke a shift in attitudes that empowers American families and deals a blow to big-government, protectionist, special interests.

Before taking office, President Joe Biden promised that most schools would be open by the end of his first 100 days in office. But then the administration scaled its plans back to include only K-8 schools. Then White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki lowered moved the goalposts again to having most schools open “at least one day a week” – and Biden later chalked up even that low standard to a “mistake in munication.” In February, Psaki waffled on whether CDC Director Rochelle Walensky was speaking in her “personal” or professional capacity when Walensky said school reopenings could take place without widespread vaccinations.

If unions continue to prefer their members’ interest in staying at home at the expense of students’ interests in being in the classroom, parents will sour on teachers’ unions. And if the parents keep up the pressure on elected officials, those officials will have to make a choice: ignore their voters, or risk losing the support of these public-sector unions, and their large and influential membership base. Either way, Californians might start to rethink their support for unions and the status quo in public education. The best thing that e out of this situation would be if overreaching teachers’ unions push parents to support school choice and individual liberty over unresponsive bureaucrats thaat put special interests ahead of their state’s children.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Wilken on Islam
One of the most thought-provoking articles I’ve read lately is Robert Louis Wilken’s “Christianity Face to Face with Islam,” in the January 2009 issue of First Things. It’s accessible online only to subscribers, but you can find the publication at academic and high-quality municipal libraries and it will be freely available online in a month or two. Wilken makes so many interesting and informed observations that I don’t know where to start. Among the points to ponder: “In the long...
Ignorance, Humility, and Economics
I like Robert Samuelson’s recent column about the difficulty (impossibility?) of accurately analyzing economic reality, let alone predicting its future. Over the past several months a few people, mistaking me for someone who knows a great deal about economics, have asked what I think about the financial crisis, the stock market, the recession, etc. My response is usually something along the lines of the following: Anyone who pretends to know and pletely the causes of the economic meltdown and/or how...
Acton Commentary: A Second Opinion on Employer Responsibility for Heath Care
Health care reform is likely to move back into the public eye as a new Congress and a new Obama administration prepare to start work this month. In this week’s Acton Commentary, Dr. Don Condit argues for a move away from employer funded health care benefits to a portable system. “Corporate human resources departments should not be viewed as the main source of support for Americans’ health care,” he writes. “The iniquitous government subsidy for employer-based health care could be...
Book Review: My Grandfather’s Son
Perhaps the most striking theme of Associate Justice Clarence Thomas’s autobiography My Grandfather’s Son is just how many obstacles Thomas had to e to reach the high judicial position he currently holds. Thomas was born into poverty, abandoned by his father, and was raised in the segregated South all before achieving the American Dream. At the same time, it was Thomas’s poverty-stricken circumstances that would help propel him to a world of greater opportunity. Because of his mother’s poverty, when...
Farewell, Father Neuhaus
First Things has announced that Father Richard John Neuhaus died this morning. I am hardly qualified to write a eulogy, having never met the man. No doubt others, including one or two Acton colleagues who knew him better, will perform this service admirably. But I pelled to offer a few words, as I have long admired Fr. Neuhaus and his vital work, in particular the journal he edited for many years, First Things (FT). In the mid-1990s, I was a...
Movie Review: Valkyrie
The year is 1943 and Valkyrie, the second release under the revamped United Artists brand, opens with German officer Claus von Stauffenberg (Tom Cruise) on assignment in Africa. He had been sent there because his opposition to Hitler and the Nazi regime had e dangerously explicit and bellicose. His promotion to lieutenant-colonel of the general staff and transfer from the European lines to Africa is intended to give him some protection from pro-Nazi officers who might make trouble for him....
Why We Give — Liberal and Conservative
Nicholas Kristof’s Dec. 21 New York Times column was, he says, “a transparent attempt this holiday season to shame liberals into being more charitable.” He quotes Arthur Brooks’ “Who Really Cares” book which shows that conservatives give more to charity than liberals. The upshot is that Democrats, who speak passionately about the hungry and homeless, personally fork over less money to charity than Republicans — the ones who try to cut health insurance for children. “When I started doing research...
Christmas and the Cross
Two of Eric Shansberg’s recent PowerBlog posts got me thinking of some other things I had run across in the last couple weeks during the run-up to Christmas Day. The first item, “Santa and the ultimate Fairy Tale,” quotes Tony Woodlief to the effect that “fairy tales and Santa Claus do prepare us to embrace the ultimate Fairy Tale.” Schansberg’s (and Woodlief’s) take on this question is pelling and worth considering, even though I’m not quite convinced of the value...
One Good Thing about Term Limits
I’m ambivalent about the value of term limits, but one thing that can certainly be counted in their favor is that they (at some point at least), force lawmakers to go out and try to make a living in the economic environment which they helped to shape. In Michigan, nearly half of the 110-member House of Representatives will consist of new members. Of the 46 new members, 44 ing from seats that were open because of term limits. And now...
Conservative/Libertarian Books for the Acton Reader
It is the new year and the time of reflection is upon us. In 2008, we witnessed a revolutionary left-liberal presidential victory and the onset of substantial economic challenges. Under the circumstances, I thought now might be a good time to propose a list of outstanding books for the intellectually curious friend or fellow traveler. I would not dare attempt to put these in order based on excellence. Just consider it a series of number ones. 1. Lancelot by Walker...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved