Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
A rift with ‘Europe,’ or just the EU?
A rift with ‘Europe,’ or just the EU?
Jan 16, 2026 3:24 AM

After last weekend’s G-7 and NATO summits, leading figures would have the world believe that transatlantic relations are rougher than ever, literally as well as figuratively. The media have highlighted such ephemera as President Trump’s allegedly pushing the prime minister of Montenegro and his white-knuckle handshake with French President Emmanuel Macron. European politicians, however, speak in starker tones about the twin threats of a Trump presidency and an impending Brexit.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel announced her despair at a campaign rally in a Munich beer hall on Sunday. “The times in which we could rely fully on others, they are somewhat over,” she said. While she remains a “convinced transatlanticist,” she said the time e that “we must fight for our future on our own, for our destiny as Europeans.”

The proximate cause of her grief was Trump’s potentially pulling out of the Paris climate agreement, which Merkel deemed “a central agreement for shaping globalization.”

Such is its significance that Donald Tusk, president of the European Council, would instruct the United States to focus on “values … not just interests.” Italian Prime Minister Paolo Gentiloni then extolled “fundamental principles, such as mitment to fight climate change.”

No one exceeded Merkel’s rival for the chancellorship, Social Democratic Party leader Martin Schulz, who said that the present U.S. administration had e “the destroyer of all Western values.”

“Europe is the answer,” Schultz offered. “Stronger cooperation among the European countries at all levels is the answer to Donald Trump.”

Eurocrats have consistently invoked a vision of an “ever-closer union,” ever more firmly consolidated under their control inBrussels. But in the context of the EU, “centralization means a lack of democracy,” as Tomasz Poreba, a Member of European Parliament from Poland, said at the first Conservatives International – Americas conference in Miami over the weekend. The more remotethe level of governance, the less any individual can influence it and the greater it is subject to cronyism.

Furthermore, reticence about the Paris climate agreement is well-founded and shared by many Eastern European nations behind the scenes. In order to meet its targets, the price of emitting carbon dioxide would have to rise by 1,000 percent in Europe. “To the extent the Paris accord increases political control over human and natural resources, it will make the world poorer and technological progress less likely,” the Wall Street Journal has warned.

It is far from clear that empowering supranational governing bodies and increasing the price of energy are bedrock transatlantic values.

Still, Merkel told the Munich crowd that, inside the G-7 meeting in Sicily, support for the Paris agreement ran “six – if you count the European Union, seven – against one.” It is precisely this assertion that the EU – led by four nations already represented in the G-7 Summit – is a co-equal and independent entity that the United States and a growing number of Euroskeptics are unwilling to tolerate.

This is especially true when many of those insisting the United States adhere to modern secular progressive “values” have not upheld their promise to adequately contribute to NATO. Only five of NATO’s 28 members meet their obligation to spend two percent of their GDP on defense. If every nation had done so, it would have amounted to $119 billionlast year alone, President Trump said in Brussels.

The United States is doing Europe no favors by alleviating the continent’s need to pay for its own defense. Indications are funds that otherwise would have gone to defense – a core function for which governments are instituted among men – instead go to fund the EU’s generous welfare state. Such programs, Pope John Paul II wrote in Centesimus Annus, lead to “a loss of human energies and an inordinate increase of public agencies, which are dominated more by bureaucratic ways of thinking than by concern for serving their clients.”

That is by no meansto say that there are no failings in Washington, D.C. On Tuesday, President Trump tweetedthat the “MASSIVE trade deficit with Germany…will change.” A potential trade war with Germany would, indeed, create a gulf within the transatlantic alliance.

However, urging leaders to fund central government responsibilities and avoid costly agreements that sap energy (both human and natural) does nothing to harm “Europe.” Such principles are valid for every nation. The current rift is not between the United States and “Europe” but between the U.S. and the EU superstructure. And Brussels’ agenda already faces serious opposition from its own 28 (soon to be 27) member states.

At some point, the EU must implement policies that stimulate economic growth and development, and allow more breathing room within its “ever-closer union,” or it will speak to an ever-smaller – and ever-poorer – constituency.

(Photo: President Donald Trump flanked by European Council President Donald Tusk, left, and European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker, right. Photo credit: Shealah Craighead, the White House. Public domain.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
21st Annual Dinner: In Case You Missed It
The full video of our 21st Annual Dinner is now up: Acton Executive Director Kris Alan Mauren, Kate O’Beirne as master of ceremonies, AU alumnus Gareth Bloor, Bishop Hurley of Grand Rapids, special address by Acton President Rev. Robert A. Sirico, and keynote address by John O’Sullivan. Acton’s Faith and Freedom Award was presented to Mr. O’Sullivan on behalf of Lady Margaret Thatcher, who sent her former advisor and speechwriter in her place. Part I: Part II: ...
Another Amazing Grace: Wisdom & Wonder Book Launch in Grand Rapids
In preparation for this Saturday’s Grand Rapids book launch of Wisdom & Wonder, the latest translation from the Dutch theologian, journalist, and politician Abraham Kuyper,The Grand Rapids Press ran an excellent article in the religion section over the weekend. Press reporter Ann Byle did a great job explaining plexities of the content of Wisdom & Wonder: Common Grace in Science & Art and how that connects with the mon grace work that we are translating. We hope to have Volume...
Audio: Michael Matheson Miller on Real Solutions to Poverty
Acton’s Director of Media Michael Matheson Miller was in-studio this morning on The Tony Gates Show on WJRW Radio to talk about global poverty, PovertyCure, and his pleted trip to London to speak about those issues at an Acton conference. To listen to the interview, use the audio player below: [audio: ...
Abraham Kuyper is Dead
Abraham Kuyper (1837-1920), the multi-talented Dutch theologian, statesman, and journalist, is dead. But a new group has formed to make sure that his ideas and legacy are not. As Chris Meehan of CRC Communications reports, the Abraham Kuyper Translation Society has been formed to “translate and promote books, articles and other materials written by Dutch theologian Abraham Kuyper.” Kuyper College will act as the host institution for the society, which involves scholars from a variety of institutions around the world....
Audio: Jordan Ballor on Ecumenical Babel
Acton Research Fellow Jordan Ballor – who also serves as Executive Editor of the Journal of Markets and Morality – took to the airwaves in the Houston, Texas area last night to discuss the ecumenical movement, his book, Ecumenical Babel,and Christian social thought with the hosts of A Show of Faith on News Talk 1070 AM. To listen to the interview, use the audio player below: [audio: ...
‘Wisdom Begins in Wonder’
“Wisdom begins in wonder.” This is a popular paraphrase of Socrates from Plato’s Theatetus, which focuses on the relationship between philosophy and knowledge. Dr. Mel Flikkema, provost at Kuyper College, reminded us of this justly famous quotation as he introduced the launch event for Wisdom & Wonder: Common Grace in Science & Art by Abraham Kuyper this past Saturday morning. Vincent Bacote describes "Another Amazing Grace."This was a splendidly appropriate introduction to the morning’s event, as the talk by Dr....
Social Business, Social Gospel, Social Justice
Friedrich Hayek called it a weasel word. The American Spectator has my new essay on it here. More on social justice as it appears in Catholic social teaching here. And more on social business here. ...
‘Bond Aid for Brussels’
In my opinion, those ing from the mouth of Declan Ganley were the most memorable from our distinguished speakers at yesterday’s conference “From Aid to Enterprise: Economic Liberty and Solutions to Poverty” in London. pared what European governments were doing in their attempts to deal with their sovereign debt problems with the attempts of rock stars to solve the problem of hunger in Africa with Live Aid back in the 1980s. It was just one of many precious ing from...
Rev. Robert A. Sirico at Georgetown Roundtable Discussion
The Berkley Center for Religion, Peace, & World Affairs at Georgetown University and the Governance Studies Program at The Brookings Institution have invited Rev. Robert A. Sirico, president and co-founder of the Acton Institute, to join a December 6 roundtable discussion in Washington on economics and Catholic Social Teaching. The event is free and open to the public. Friends of Acton in the Washington area are encouraged to attend the talk. Questions will be invited from the floor at the...
Sirico at Georgetown: Good Intentions Depend upon Sound Economics
On Tuesday, Acton’s president, Rev. Robert A. Sirico, joined three other prominent Catholic thinkers for a roundtable discussion of the U.S. bishops’ 1986 letter “Economic Justice for All.” Georgetown Univeristy’s Berkley Center for Religion, Peace, and World Affairs sponsored the discussion, and Berkley Center director Tom Banchoff moderated the proceedings. The discussion, held on the left-leaning document’s 25th anniversary, addressed its legacy. Fr. Sirico’s contention was that the bishops “exceed[ed] their authority in an area where they petency,” in a...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved