Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
3 Reasons income tax cuts (almost) always benefit the wealthy
3 Reasons income tax cuts (almost) always benefit the wealthy
Jan 11, 2026 11:35 PM

Death and taxes may be the only certainties in life, but there is a close third: e tax cuts mostly benefit e workers.

As Congress discusses tax reform, the debate about who will benefit from tax cuts is back in the news. And many people are concerned with how the changes will favor high e earners. Even President Trump has promised that the reforms won’t give wealthy Americans a massive tax cut.

The reality is that there is almost no way to cut e taxes without most of the benefits going to e workers. Here are three reasons why:

1. Americans with high es pay most of the taxes

The intended goal of reducing taxes on Americans can have a significant affect on whose taxes are being cut. For example, let’s say the goal is to cut e taxes to return a specific amount of money back to citizens—$500 billion—in the hopes of stimulating consumer spending.

If that is our goal, then we can’t cut the e taxes paid by the bottom 45 percent of American earners. Why? Because they already don’t pay any e taxes.

As Politico notes, the top 0.1 percent of earners are projected to pay more to the IRS than the bottom 80 bined. And for 2017, official government data shows the top 20 percent will pay 95 percent of all e taxes. The rich benefit from e tax cutsbecause they pay most of the e taxes.

2. Americans with lower es already have low tax rates

But what if instead of focusing on a dollar amount, we just cut e tax rates? Couldn’t we just cut the rates on the lower rungs of the e ladder? Not really, because they are already low.

The average federal tax rate for people whose earnings put them in the 21st to 80th percentile of es has fallen by 30 percent since 1979 to 13.8 percent. Rates on e people have declined even further, by 57 percent, to 3.3 percent. If we cut the lowest rate by 1 percent it might save a worker $100 a year.

“The fact that they don’t pay very much in taxes means that it’s very hard to provide them with a large tax cut,” says Adam Looney, a former deputy assistant Treasury secretary for tax analysis in the Obama administration.

3. Marginal tax cuts benefit everyone

e taxes are based on marginal rates, the amount of tax paid on an additional dollar of e. Here’s an example of a marginal tax rate bracket.

10% for e $0 to $9,275

15% for e $9,275 to $37,650

25% for e $37,650 to $91,150

28% for e $91,150 to $190,150

33% for e $190,150 to $413,350

35% for e $413,350 to $415,050

39.6% for e $415,050+

Let’s say we want to lower the taxes for everyone making $90,000 or less, so we reduce the 25 percent bracket to 20 percent, the 15 to 10 percent and the 10 to 7. (For the sake of simplicity, we’ll assume there are no deductions, including no standard deduction.)

The effect would be that someone making $9,000 a year would pay $270 less in taxes, someone making $35,000 would pay $1,750 less, and someone earning $50,000 a year would pay $2,500 less.

But the person making $100,000 would also save about $20,390 because of the lower marginal rates. The worker making $9,000 saw her taxes reduced by 3 percent but the person making $100,000 had a more than 20 percent reduction.

“It’s basically impossible to have a large tax cut that doesn’t involve most of the benefits going to e groups just because that’s who pays taxes now,” says Looney.

The real questions Americans—especially American Christians—should be asking is, “Why does it matter?” Why are we so worried that the wealthy may be getting some sort of advantage that is out of proportion to what we may be getting? Perhaps we should be less concerned on sinful class envy and more focused on developing prudent tax policies that benefit everyone and lead to greater economic flourishing.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Agog and Aghast at Google
A number of bloggers have expressed grave concerns over Google’s decision to odate the demands of munist government in its web search offerings in China. David Mills at Mere Comments writes that Google is “serving a brutal government and helping it oppress its people, even if its service will prove only partially effective.” plains that Google’s motives are purely pecuniary, and that pany is only acceding to the government’s wishes because “If it didn’t help the Chinese government oppress its...
Celebrating Bonhoeffer
PBS stations across the country will be airing Bonhoeffer, “an acclaimed dramatic documentary about theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer. The documentary “tells the story of the young German pastor who offered one of the first clear voices of resistance to Adolf Hitler and the rise of the National Socialist (Nazi) Party.” The shows will air on Monday, February 6, celebrating the 100th anniversary of Bonhoeffer’s birth on February 4, 1906. You can check your local listings here for dates and times when...
Why Johnny can’t compete with Sanjay
The math and science skills of American high schoolers and college students continue to erode. Michael Miller looks at the implications for U.S. petitiveness and offers some suggestions for fixing what ails the schools. Read the mentary here. ...
Foreign aid vs. economic freedom II
Jay Richards’ previous post on Richard Rahn’s article “Not Rocket Science” illustrates Huxley’s famous statement about a fact destroying a theory. Jay quotes Rahn’s lists of the politicians and development experts who support increased foreign aid. It’s no longer just politicians and economists. Bono’s One Campaign is designed to get the developed nations to contribute 1 percent of their GDP to foreign aid for the poorest countries. No doubt Bono and many other supporters have good intentions. But good intentions...
What was that saying about power?
From the Washington Post, a snippet from Hugo Chavez, discussing Bolivia’s recently elected president, Evo Morales: “We have to create, one, two, three Bolivias in Latin America, in the Caribbean,” [Chavez] said echoing a quotation from Argentine hero Ernesto Che Guevara. “Only aiming for power can we transform the world.” Why do I get the idea Chavez didn’t do so well in his history classes? ...
Driven a Ford lately?
If you’re like most Americans, the answer is probably “No.” Faced with loss of market share and declining revenues, Ford announced a restructuring plan that would cut nearly a quarter of its workforce and close 14 plants over the next six years. The moves are intended to bring the auto giant back to profitability by 2008. What has caused petitiveness of Ford to plummet? It’s part of the larger trend among American automakers. Ford’s “Way Forward” plan was preceded by...
Created imago Dei
Winners of the 2005 Acton Essay Competition have been announced. The topic for the 15th petition: The human person, by virtue of being created imago Dei, is an independent being, individually unique, rational, the subject of moral agency, a co-creator, and inherently social. Accordingly, human persons possess intrinsic value and dignity, implying certain rights and duties with respect to the recognition and protection of the dignity of themselves and other persons. These truths about the human person’s dignity are known...
Building on the tithe
A brief opinion from yours truly, featured in the February issue of The Banner, the denominational magazine of the Christian Reformed Church in North America: “Building on the Tithe.” With an eye towards Christians in other parts of the world, I observe, “In North America the conflict we face is largely between spending our leisure or disposable e on ourselves and spending it on others.” Check out the rest. ...
Foreign aid vs. economic freedom
The abstract arguments for economic freedom are great for those of us who, well, like abstract arguments. But sometimes, there’s no substitute for some good, solid empirical data. That’s just what economist Richard Rahn delivers in this article in the Washington Times. If you don’t have time to read the 2006 Heritage Foundation/Wall Street Journal “Index of Economic Freedom,” at least read Rahn’s summary of it. He starts: Suppose you were appointed global economic czar, and your task was to...
Amazing stories of effective compassion
I was reminded recently that Jesus repeatedly underscored the high value of seemingly very small things. The significant results of small mustard seeds and lost coins made his parable points well but, as a mom, the story of one lost sheep made me quickly leap to the incalculable value of one lost person. On a planet of billions, many of whom live and die with scarcely any notice, Jesus says God notices … and cares. And He calls us to...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved