Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
The Bishops' Big Economic Tent
The Bishops' Big Economic Tent
Apr 22, 2025 3:37 AM

To the joy of Catholics who support capitalist institutions, the U.S. Bishops have at long last applied the principle of ecumenism to economic issues. The vehicle is a short ten-point “Catholic Framework for Economic Life,” passed unanimously at this year’s meeting of the National Conference of Catholic Bishops. es ten years after “Economic Justice for All” the Bishops’ controversial pastoral letter that disappointed so many businesspeople.

The new document departs from years of confusion, in which the Bishops appeared to side only with the left on economics. The statement is broader in its approach and more consistent with the Bishops’ primary realm petency: moral instruction. It is much sounder from an economic perspective, allowing ample room for holding the business economy and the free market in high regard. The Bishops embrace market institutions by name, and, in a praiseworthy departure, offer no explicit (or even implicit) endorsement of redistribution, confiscatory taxes, or regulatory management. Following are some examples of this new approach to economics.

“The economy exists for the person, not the person for the economy.” This underscores the reality–forgotten in an age of socialism and economic planning–that the economy is, in the first instance, made up of individuals who act, choose, and plan for the future. It is illegitimate to treat the economy as a posed of huge and manipulatable aggregates–to which society must be forced to conform. Economic systems must be in accord with human nature, and not the reverse.

“All economic life should be shaped by moral principles. Economic choices and institutions must be judged by how they protect or undermine the life and dignity of the human person, support the family, and serve mon good.” Both individuals and institutions are subject to this stern standard, including government and its bureaucracies. No institution has harmed family life more than big government, with its high taxes, bureaucratic red tape, and dependency-promoting welfarism. Economists from Joseph Schumpeter to Michael Novak and Gary Becker have stressed that vibrant family life and mon good are inseparably linked to private property, equal rights, and economic liberty.

“All people have a right to life and to secure the basic necessities of life.” Some in the media claimed this plank endorses welfare rights, which would be alarming. It is a small step from welfare rights to socialism. In fact, the statement says people have a right “to secure” necessities, and this qualifying phrase makes all the difference. A right to secure something is not the same as a right to the thing itself; securing requires initiative and action. There is no normative right to others’ property, but only to secure necessities for ourselves in a manner consistent with others’ rights.

I don’t claim my free-market take on this statement is the definitive rendering, but herein lies the beauty of the Bishops’ ten points. They have provided a moral framework that embraces markets, rejects socialism and excessive government management, calls upon people to put morality at the center of decision making, while tolerating divergent opinions on the details.

The Bishops are doing what they do best: providing moral and ethical guidance for individuals and societies. As John Paul II says, “In her social doctrine the Church does not propose a concrete political or economic model, but indicates the way, presents principles.”

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Two Rules to Tackle America’s Debt
  The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) just released the February 2024 Budget and Economic Outlook, and projections look grim. This year, net interest cost—the federal government’s interest payments on debt held by the public minus interest income—stands at a staggering $659 billion in 2023 and has recently soared to about $1 trillion. Unless politicians face these facts and restrain spending, Americans...
Taking On the College Cartel
  The venerable economist Milton Friedman once said, “Only a crisis—actual or perceived—produces real change.” That’s the impulse behind Winston Churchill’s admonition (later famously echoed by Obamas chief of staff Rahm Emanuel): “Never let a good crisis go to waste.” Well, welcome to the world of American higher education. Crippling tuition, bloated bureaucracies, huge rates of noncompletion, campus groupthink, DEI loyalty...
Connecting in the Heat of Conflict
  Connecting in the Heat of the Moment   By: Amanda Idleman   Since God chose you to be the holy people he loves, you must clothe yourselves with tenderhearted mercy, kindness, humility, gentleness, and patience. - Colossians 3:12   At all times in our marriages, we need to connect heart-to-heart, which means connecting emotionally before anything else.   Have you ever had an argument...
A Comedy of Bureaucratic Errors
  The Apple original series Slow Horses centers around a man who has fought two wars. The world-worn Jackson Lamb, brilliantly performed by Gary Oldman, is disheveled, indifferent, and bitter. And he’s got every right to be because he’s not only been fighting against the Soviets and numerous security threats to the UK, but has also battled the large institutional bureaucracy...
Three Body Problems
  Classical liberals are rightly accused of droning on about the pitfalls of state control and the hubris of planners. The reason we get so tedious about it is, well, because we’re right: Many of the problems we face are caused by overconfident planners who presume to know the way things should be run for the rest of us. From farm...
A Lenten Prayer to Bring Beauty from Ashes
  A Lenten Prayer for God to Bring Beauty from Ashes   By Debbie McDaniel   “To bestow on them a crown of beauty instead of ashes, the oil of joy instead of mourning, and a garment of praise instead of a spirit of despair.”Isa 61:3   As we walk through this season of Lent, we’re reminded again that sometimes… life is hard.   Sometimes...
What Prayer Isn’t About
  Weekend, March 16, 2024   What Prayer Isn’t About   Seek the Kingdom of God above all else, and live righteously, and he will give you everything you need. (Matthew 6:33 NLT)   Prayer isn’t about changing God’s mind. In many cases, prayer is about changing our minds.   When Jesus taught His disciples to pray, He told them, “Pray like this: Our Father...
White Evangelicals Want Christian Influence, Not a ‘Christian Nation’
  In a country where 80 percent of adults believe religions influence is in decline, white evangelicals stand out as the group most likely to want to see their faith reflected in the US government.   According to a new survey from the Pew Research Center, most white evangelicals want a president who reflects their religious beliefs, believe the Bible should have...
The Path to Disincorporation
  The Supreme Court over the last two decades has repeatedly strengthened the expanded reach of the Free Exercise and Free Speech Clauses to protect the religious. At the same time, the Court has moved to reduce the weight of the Establishment Clause as a counterbalance to the reach and protections of these other clauses—a counterbalance that it obtained through a...
Sympathy for the Devil
  Universities are one of the United States’ greatest strengths. Throughout the nation’s history, institutions of higher education have promoted free thought and open discourse, which are crucial to maintaining our stable democracy and unparalleled economic growth. Attendance was viewed as a clear benefit for both the student and society. But the legitimacy of American higher education is under attack and...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved