Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Religious toleration in a religious state
Religious toleration in a religious state
Apr 20, 2025 9:26 AM

The concepts of toleration espoused by theologians in the officially religious states of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries deserve closer examination. So argue Tobias Dienst and Christoph Strohm in their introduction to Martinus Becanus’s 1607 treatise, On the Duty to Keep Faith with Heretics. Becanus (1563–1624), a Dutch Jesuit theologian who became court confessor to the Holy Roman Emperor, lived in and supported an officially Roman Catholic state, but this did not prevent him from developing a concept of religious toleration that viewed the toleration of Protestants and other religious adherents as advancing the greater good of society.

This work is not principally a work on religious toleration. Becanus’s main concern is to defend the thesis “that it is morally obligatory to fulfill all contracts and promises unless they are against divine law or in another way invalid.” Specifically, Becanus shows that one must keep one’s promises and honor one’s contracts regardless of the religious views of the other party. Yet, as Dienst and Strohm point out, this principle “also applies to agreements granting religious tolerance to heretics.” The matter of religious toleration is thus a part of the moral question of whether, and in what circumstances, one must keep one’s promises. Like most writers in the tumultuous religious and political context of the early modern era, Becanus did not endorse religious freedom and freedom of conscience as goods to be pursued in themselves. This is clear from his stark denunciations of unqualified religious liberty. Yet, Becanus would change his views on toleration from the more restrictive stance he takes in this treatise. Dienst and Strohm sketch his movement from regarding toleration as permissible for preventing a greater evil in society (such as religious wars) to regarding toleration as permissible for achieving a greater good (such as the possible, future conversion of religious dissenters). The authors observe that this change in Becanus’s view “is a first step toward the idea of tolerance as possibly beneficial to society and not merely as an unpreventable nuisance.”

Theologians from this era typically supported the religious states that upheld their respective confessional persuasions, and these writers often defended the use of force against religious dissenters in those states. More liberal advocates of toleration and freedom of conscience, such as Sebastian Castellio (1515–1563), often had loose confessional affiliation or were in conflict with the Catholic or Protestant authorities. Dienst and Strohm note that in the study of the history of toleration writers like Castellio have received the bulk of attention as proto-moderns, leading many scholars to “skip the time between Castellio and the early Enlightenment altogether.” That’s a gap of roughly 200 years that included hundreds of authors who wrote about toleration, liberty of conscience, and religious freedom. Becanus is one of these overlooked authors—a Catholic writer who developed the concept of religious toleration within a Catholic state. On the Duty to Keep Faith with Heretics, therefore, helps to fill a gap in mon story of the rise of religious toleration in the West.

On the Duty to Keep Faith with Heretics, edited by Wim Decock and translated by Isabelle Buhre, is the first English translation of Becanus’s treatise De fide haereticis servanda and the latest volume in CLP Academic’s Sources in Early Modern Economics, Ethics, and Law series.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
What Good Is a Christian Alternative Without Christ?
During his first term, George W. Bush promised that faith-based organizations that fought addiction and poverty would not be muted in their proclamation of the gospel. The heads of those organizations didn’t believe him. Read More… My last entry in this series on passionate conservatism movement concluded with a question: Would John DiIulio, head of the George W. Bush administration’s faith-based office, insist that religion-based programs, to be eligible for federal grants, be devoid of religious teaching or evangelism? I...
Oppenheimer and the Last Great America
Director Christopher Nolan had brought to life more than just the birth of the atomic age in his biopic of physicist J. Robert Oppenheimer. He has forged worlds. Read More… The last major director we have is Christopher Nolan. As you watch his movies, you think about what it means for there to be masters of the art: people who seem to know the tools of the art so well that they are plete control of what they’re doing, yet...
Identity Politics Is All That’s Left
George Hawley’s 2016 book, Right-Wing Critics of American Conservatism, received high marks for its balanced approach. Now he’s taken a look at the conservative response to identity politics. Unfortunately, a faulty methodology has upset that balance this time around. Read More… In a series of academic books, George Hawley has proven himself to be a thoughtful writer and thinker on American politics and its disputatious conservative and progressive elements. He is also that rare breed in contemporary academia who generally...
Hungary Is Not Viktor Orbán
Hungary’s history plicated. It’s also greater than its current leader. Hungarians still have hope for reform. What it needs is some friends. Read More… Viktor Orbán, the controversial prime minister of Hungary, has no shortage of critics or defenders. For the critics, he is an authoritarian villain, a sinister leading voice in the global populist movement. To his supporters, Orbán is a champion of traditional values, protecting the nation-state and Hungarian culture from shadowy global elites. A recent Religion and...
Young People Aren’t Becoming Conservatives. Here’s Why.
America’s biggest voting block doesn’t think conservatives “care.” To win, we have to change that. Read More… Almost everyone has heard the cynical political adage, generally attributed to Winston Churchill, that “Any man under 30 who is not a liberal has no heart, and any man over 30 who is not a conservative has no brains.” While the sentiment is lighthearted at its core, it municates a popular piece of political wisdom: as people get older and buy into the...
Alexa’s Just Not That into You
What do you do when your smart home starts outsmarting you? The dangers some forms of artificial intelligence pose are just beginning to be realized. Read More… A few weeks ago, software engineer Brandon Jackson found himself shut out of his smart home for a full week. When Alexa wouldn’t respond to mands, he called the Amazon help desk to see what the issue was. Evidently, pany locked him out because of his apparent racism: “I was told that the...
Christianity and Liberalism: The Spirituality of the Church in a Politicized World
It’s the 100th anniversary of J. Gresham Machen’s classic work. It didn’t change American Presbyterianism but should have. Was he just ahead of his time? Read More… J. Gresham Machen’s book Christianity and Liberalism, published 100 years ago, was a curious mix of theology and politics. Readers monly miss the political part if only because Machen, a Southern Presbyterian who labored in exile among Northern Presbyterians (the munions were divided from the Civil War to 1983), was a proponent of...
The Lost-and-Found Art of Self-Branding
Re-creating the self has e big business, not to mention a matter of cultural and political controversy. But this is not a new phenomenon. It’s as old as the Garden of Eden. Read More… In Genesis 1:27, we read the following: “God created mankind in his image; in the image of God he created them; male and female he created them.” We are beings inextricably linked to God, yet we are constantly striving to separate ourselves from our Creator. It’s...
The Problem of Cults in Kenya
Although the overwhelming majority of Kenyans are Christians, religious con men still have a hold on many of the poor. Bringing them to justice is difficult owing to corruption, government connections, and constitutional freedom of religion. But is what they are practicing religion at all? Read More… As of 2021, Kenya’s population was estimated to be 54.7 million, and as of 2019 “approximately 85.5 percent of the total population is Christian and 11 percent Muslim. Groups constituting less than 2...
Barbie Is a Movie for Our Time. This Is a Bad Thing.
The War of the Sexes is over. Guess who won? Nobody. Read More… When I was a college boy, one of my history professors argued persuasively, if self-interestedly, that pink was the medieval European color of manliness—it was the color of living flesh, of manly health. And I certainly admire the pinks one sees in Renaissance paintings. But I’ve never been able to see the good of it in our lives. When a man puts on a suit, it had...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved