Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Poland’s young people love free markets, not fascism: A view from Poland
Poland’s young people love free markets, not fascism: A view from Poland
Apr 20, 2025 7:46 AM

According to the international media, Poland’s March of Independence this weekend portends a growing threat of fascism in Eastern Europe. However, the media accounts may not be entirely accurate, and Polish young people fervently reject the underpinnings of fascism – because of their support for the free market.

Polish writer Marcin Rzegocki explores international media coverage of this weekend’s Polish Independence Day march in a new essay forReligion & Liberty Transatlantic. He finds that “Poland’s March of Independence was not like it’s being portrayed.” He writes:

The march has been portrayed by the mainstream media, both Polish and foreign, as a mass exercise in hatred and bigotry. This criticism was often based more on oversimplifications and stereotypes than a true accounting of all the facts. Indeed, some of the articles are not based on facts at all. …CNNandThe Washington Postpublished articles suggesting that the march’s motto was “Pray for Islamic Holocaust,” something latersharedon social media by former Hillary Clinton spokesman Jesse Lenrich. In fact, this phrase was taken from a banner hung at an entirely different rally, in the city of Poznań,in 2015.

The march is a fast-growing but relatively new phenomenon, he notes, one that has taken on an air of defiance as Poles who uphold traditional values and pro-liberty philosophies felt increasingly isolated:

The march, which takes place in Warsaw, has grown over the last decade from hundreds of participants to more than 70,000 in 2016. This year nearly 60,000 mostly young people and families participated. It has also grown into an ever-larger symbol of resistance by the younger generation to the ideologies of socialism, atheism, gender fluidity, multiculturalism, and new models to replace the traditional family. It is true that the march was originally organized by the National Radical Camp and All-Polish Youth, two nationalist associations, and some of the marchers held indefensible views. Nevertheless, since 2010 the March of Independence has attracted generally patriotic Poles who do not share those organizations’agendas. It has instead e the marchers’ expression oftheir belief in the traditional values of faith, family, and patriotism (notnationalism). It grew into a protest against leftist culture during the most recent administration of the left-wing Civic Platform (Platforma Obywatelska, or PO) from 2007 to 2015. This year’s march slogan was “We Want God” – the opening words of a famous Catholic hymnquotedby President Donald Trump duringhis speech in Warsawearlier this year.

Poland has been presented as teetering on the edge of fascism due to the actions of its ruling Law and Justice Party. The party has been accused of threatening the independence of the judiciary and trying to curtail the freedom of the press.

There is clear reason for hope, Rzegocki writes. After analyzing copious amounts of polling piled over the course of 27 years, Marcin finds that young Polish voters reject the party heartily – and not just for civil libertarian reasons. Young Poles have shifted away from describing themselves as “on the Right” because of the party’s intervention in the economy.

Their love of the free market may help Poland stave off the allegedly growing threat of fascism.

Marcin writes:

This change is significant, if viewed through contemporary Polish politics. Young people in Poland shifting from “Right” to “undecided” is, by some observers, associated with the fact that the major party that is identified with the Right, Law and Justice (Prawo i Sprawiedliwość), isdefactoin favor ofstate intervention in economics. Young people who support the free market reject the party on these grounds. …International observers concerned about the Law and Justice Party should be pleased that young people support free markets and, on that basis, other political options. Supporting the market distances voters from any historic form of fascism. Without that viewpoint, events may indeed push them one day to embrace the very political and cultural options that observers fear.

Read his full essay here.

/ Shutterstock.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The more things change …
A 1934 cartoon by Pulitzer Prize winner Carey Orr published in the Chicago Tribune. Snopes is still checking. ...
A Micro-Lending Prelate
Zenit reports a new initiative by Cardinal Crescenzio Sepe of Naples, Italy: “he is donating a year’s stipend and part of his personal savings to initiate a diocesan bank that will offer micro-credits to the poor.” I like two things about this project. First, the cardinal is putting his own money to work, furnishing a good example of mitment to assist those in need. Second, he is doing so in a thoughtful and creative way, not “throwing money” at a...
PBR: A Cautionary Tale
AS NYT columnist Frank Rich observed earlier this week, it’s hard to find much sympathy for Rick Wagoner. “Sure, Rick Wagoner deserved his fate,” writes Rich. “He did too little too late to save an iconic American institution from devolving into a government charity case.” The delusions of the CEOs who lined up on Capitol Hill last year to lobby for bailouts extended beyond the arrogance of flying to congressional meetings in private jets. Duly chastened, the CEOs next made...
Easter: The Resurrection & the Life
Jesus said to her, “I am the resurrection and the life. He who believes in me will live, even though he dies; and whoever lives and believes in me will never die. Do you believe this?” – John 11: 25, 26 The es from the account of Lazarus being raised to life by Christ after already being dead for four days. The question “Do you believe this?” was posed to the sister of Lazarus, Martha. There have been people who...
The Tax Code: Business as Usual
In this week’s Acton Commentary, I argue for simplifying the tax code. It should also be evident that any sort of tax reform should coincide with reforming the way Washington currently operates when es to spending. April 15th is of course tax day, and national protests will also be occurring across this nation under the historically significant title of “tea parties.” One of the points I made in my piece is that it is important that these protests are not...
A Quick Response to the Christianity Trailing Off Thesis
I recently received a request from a reporter to respond to the recent spate of studies and stories positing a decline in American Christianity. Here’s how I answered: Broadly speaking, it is silly to think of secularization as a linear process. The prominence of the Christian faith waxes and wanes during different historical periods. As Rodney Stark has pointed out, the old golden age of faith picture of antiquity is not nearly as strong as many believe. There is, however,...
Warren on the Faith-Based Initiative
In a wide-ranging interview with Christianity Today, Rick Warren discussed his view of the new vision for the faith-based initiative. Here’s that Q&A: Have you paid attention to the new faith-based initiatives released by President Obama and Joshua DuBois focusing on the four issues of responsible fatherhood, reducing unintended pregnancies, increasing interfaith dialogue, and reducing poverty? Those are great goals. My fear is that if all of a sudden you have promise your convictions to be part of the faith...
David W. Miller interviewed on PBS
Dr. David W. Miller, who was interviewed in Religion & Liberty for the Winter 2008 issue, was recently on a PBS program discussing corporate morality. Here is a portion of the PBS interview which relates to the theme in Acton’s R&L interview titled “Theology at Work: Faithful Living in the Marketplace:” (anchor) ABERNETHY: You, as I said, you used to work in the financial business. What do your friends there, the friends that you have who’ve worked there — what...
PBR: President Obama Responds
President Obama took time out over the weekend to respond to this week’s PBR question: “Let me assure you in the days ahead my administration intends to do to every industry in this country exactly what we are doing to the automakers.” ...
PBR: Ministries that Matter
Starting this year, the Acton Institute is planning to give out the Samaritan Award every other year. This will allows us to better streamline the award process as well as to more smoothly integrate the results of the award into our Samaritan Guide database. In recent years the Samaritan Award finalists have been profiled in a special issue of WORLD Magazine (here’s the link to the 2008 issue). But this year the folks at WORLD are taking the opportunity to...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved