Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
3 reasons to study the Russian Revolution today, according to Dutch lovers of liberty
3 reasons to study the Russian Revolution today, according to Dutch lovers of liberty
Apr 26, 2025 6:53 PM

The Bolshevik Revolution was one of the epochal events of modern history, continuing to affect the world in which we live 28 years after the fall of the Berlin Wall. Modern governments and systems of economics were created in imitation, or opposition, of its fundamental tenets. Too much of the memoration of its centenary last week consisted of celebration by its intellectual heirs. However, lovers of liberty across the transatlantic sphere also paused to reflect upon the occasion.

On October 27, supporters of a free society in the Netherlands (who call themselves “liberals”) held one such event titled, “The Russian Revolution then and now.“Its emcee was Patrick Van Schie, director of the Telders Foundation, a Dutch free market-oriented think tank that co-hosted the event with the VVD-Thematic Network International and the European Liberal Forum.

“You might wonder why liberal organizations memorating the Russian Revolution,” he said. “Our answer then is threefold.”

The first reason, he said, is that munist power grab in Petrograd and consolidation of Lenin’s regime in Russia marked the realization of a liberal dystopia. Communism is in every respect the opposite of what liberals strive for.”

“It stands,” he said, “for:

exulting the collective over the individual;dictatorship over democracy;censorship over free speech;state terror over civil rights and limited, accountable state power;a centrally planned economy over a free market-oriented economy.”

Secondly, we remember its significance for the way the West reacted – or failed to react –to Communism. “The survival of Lenin’s regime in Russia and its expansion to other countries after the Second World War – in Eastern Europe, east Asia, and Cuba – started a new phase in international relations. Without the October Revolution and its consequences, we have we would have never known the Cold War,” Van Schie said.

Americans understand the distortions that crept into American political and economic life as a result of the 44-year standoff. Rock-ribbed conservative politicians became willing to tolerate budget-busting levels of domestic spending in order to maintain an adequate Defense budget. President Reagan saw that the moribund Soviet economy would collapse from a robust arms race … but high cumulative levels of deficit spending coupled with the historically low economic growth during the last administration have threatened to capsize the U.S. economy. The Cato Institute recently held a symposium on the degree to which the Bolshevik Revolution increased the size and scope of government in the West.

“The third reason for liberals memorate 1917,” Van Schie said, is “the lasting influence of the Russian Revolution on that country,” i.e., modern Russia. He asked, “Is the Putin regime some kind of revival of tsarism, a continuation of the Soviet Union (mind you, Putin made his career in the KGB!), or bination of both?”

Polls show Josef Stalin remains popular, perhaps the most popular man in Russia. Modern Russia seeks to integrate the USSR’s status as a global superpower into its broader history, without grappling with the totalitarian oppression that panied it. Such a selective reading of history is untenable for any people and, as history has long shown, when people begin to pine for the glory days delivered by a previous dictator, the consequent suppression and denial of human rights temporarily refresh their memories about the true nature of authoritarianism.

The Telders Community has a write-up of the event, which included Sean McMeekin, author of The Russian Revolution: A New History; KoertDebeuf, director of The Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy (TIMEP) Europe; and Tony van der Togt, a researcher at the Clingdael Institute. You may also enjoyPatrick Van Schie’s column on the centenaryof Communism andhisreview of McMeekin’s book.(All links are in Dutch.)

The author is grateful to Patrick Van Schie for providing the notes of his talk for position of this article.

domain.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
From Edwards to Darwin, Abraham to Jesus
Two quick items: First, in unrelated projects, the works of Jonathan Edwards (HT: Reformation21) and Charles Darwin (HT: Slashdot) are set to be digitized and accessible online. Looks like the Darwin set plete, and the Edwards works are in public beta, with only the Miscellanies and sermons available as yet. And second, I’m headed to the exhibit, “From Abraham to Jesus,” tonight, called “the largest touring exhibit of sacred text, biblical art, and artifacts in history.” The tour opens in...
Not as Sick as You Think
In a column yesterday, George Will coined a term that deserves widespread use: economic hypochondria. He criticizes the way in which the media—and many of us, even though relatively “healthy,” financially—pounce on every bit of news that might be interpreted as indicating economic hardship. Will’s column has a certain partisan bent to it, but one needn’t be a Republican to see the larger point. As liberal writer Gregg Easterbrook observed in The Progress Paradox, even the poorest Americans enjoy a...
The Catholicity of the Reformation: Musings on Reason, Will, and Natural Law, Part 4
As promised in Part 3, this post will begin a discussion of natural law in the thought of the Reformer Peter Martyr Vermigli (1499-1562), but first I want to touch on the broader issue of natural law in the context of Reformation theology. More than any other Reformer, John Calvin is appealed to for his insight on natural law. This is probably due to the stubborn persistence among scholars to single him out as the chief early codifier of Protestant...
Capitalism and the Common Good: The Ten Pillars of the Moral Economy
Sirico: No moral conflicts with rooting for the Tigers On Friday afternoon, Rev. Robert A. Sirico addressed an audience of Acton Supporters at the Detroit Athletic Club in Detroit, Michigan. His address was titled Capitalism and the Common Good: The Ten Pillars of the Moral Economy, and we are pleased to make it available to you here (10.5 mb mp3 file). I would be remiss if I failed to note that the event took place on the eve of the...
Moyers/Beisner/Akin Kerfuffle
As noted here, last week PBS ran a special by Bill Moyers’, “Is God Green?” examining the “new” trend among evangelicals toward stewardship of the environment. Arguably what is “new” about this move is its coherence with liberal/leftist environmentalism. As also noted previously, “The munity for 5,000 years or more has taken its responsibility for the environment seriously. The whole concept of ‘stewardship’ is one es directly from sacred texts.” Stewardship isn’t new. Perhaps the method for stewardship proposed is....
Transforming Lives in Nashville
NASHVILLE – The event was billed as an “appreciation” for the volunteers at the Christian Women’s Job Corps of Middle Tennessee and the theme for the evening was set by St. Paul’s Epistle to the Galatians: Let us not e weary in doing good, for at the proper time we will reap a harvest if we do not give up (Gal. 6:9). By the time the program wrapped up, everyone in attendance was reminded of the plain truth that making...
Faithfulness in Biblical Interpretation
I ran across the following quote from Søren Kierkegaard recently (HT: the evangelical outpost): The matter is quite simple. The Bible is very easy to understand. But we Christians are a bunch of scheming swindlers. We pretend to be unable to understand it because we know very well that the minute we understand we are obliged to act accordingly. Take any words in the New Testament and forget everything except pledging yourself to act accordingly. My God, you will say,...
Power
Zenit published the following this weekend, mentary by Capuchin Father Raniero Cantalamessa on this Sunday’s liturgical readings (Isaiah 53:2a.,3a.,10-11; Hebrews 4:14-16; Mark 10:35-45). Well worth the read. After the Gospel on riches, this Sunday’s Gospel gives us Christ’s judgment on another of the great idols of the world: power. Power, like money, is not intrinsically evil. God describes himself as “the Omnipotent” and Scripture says “power belongs to God” (Psalm 62:11). However, given that man had abused the power granted...
Stossel and Symmetric Information
Jim Aune, blogger-in-chief at The plained yesterday about his health care treatment. He says, “I have been in constant pain for 36 hours. I actually used a cane to go to the office yesterday for some meetings. The problem? I have a trapped nerve in my abdomen from a double hernia repair a year ago. I got shot up with steroids about 3 weeks ago, and that worked for about 5 days, but I still can’t walk without a ripping...
Beisner Responds
In the latest Interfaith Stewardship Alliance newsletter, dated Oct. 21, Cal Beisner passes along his response to the letters sent by Bill Moyers’ legal counsel (background on the matter with related links here). Here’s what Beisner says as related through his own counsel: Your letter of October 18, 2006, to Interfaith Stewardship Alliance and your letter of October 19, 2006, to Dr. E. Calvin Beisner have been sent to me by my clients for reply. I have carefully examined the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved