The Nestorianism Heresy and Controversy

　　Nestorius was consecrated bishop of Constantinople on this date April 10th, 428. His elevation to thisinfluential position had profound repercussions for the church. A firmopponent of the Arian heresy, he was accused of falling into a contraryerror.

　　

Nestorianism Quick Facts

Nestorianism (5th Century)

　　This heresy taught Mary only gave birth to Jesus’ human nature. The founder of the heresy, Nestorius, did not even want Mary to be called “Mother of God” but instead wanted her to be called “Mother of Christ.” In essence, the heresy maintained Jesus was really two separate persons, and only the human Jesus was in Mary’s womb. If that was true, then Jesus was not God incarnate while in the womb.

　　Leader(s) in the Heresy: Nestorius of Antioch (Bishop of Constantinople in 428AD)

　　Corrector(s) of the Heresy: The Council of Ephesus in 431AD

　　Arians taught that Christ was a created being. To refute this andother points, Nestorius argued that the Godhead joined with the humanrather as if a man entered a tent or put on clothes. Instead ofdepicting Christ as one unified person, Nestorius saw him as aconjunction of two natures so distinct as to be different persons whohad merged.

　　Nestorius refused to call Mary the "Mother of God." Herbaby was very human, he said. Jesus' human acts and sufferings were ofhis human nature, not his Godhead. To say Mary was Mother of God was tosay God had once been a few hours old. "God is not a baby two orthree months old," he argued.

　　He never denied that Christ was divine. On the contrary, it was toprotect Christ's divinity that he argued as he did, lest it be lost inworship of the human child. The divine nature could not be born of awoman. Nestorius' refusal to use the term "theotokus," Motherof God, led to a big argument. He pointed out that the apostles andearly church fathers never employed the word. But he could not resolvethe issue so as to bring into focus the Jesus we know from scripture whois completely and truly both God and man.

　　

The Heresy of Nestorianism

The Nestorian teaching originated in the school of Antioch, and was taught by Diodorus and by Theodore, bishop of Mopsuestia. What was the heresy? These men did not accept the Orthodox belief that the human and divine natures of Christ were united from the instant of the Word's conception in the womb of Mary. A symbol of this controversy was the acceptance or non-acceptance of the title, "Theotokos," or "God Bearer," translated in the West to "Mother of God," for the Virgin Mary. Of course that did not mean that Mary was the Mother of the eternal and indivisible Trinity, but that she was the mother, not just of the man Christ, but of the complete God-man. It was and remains in the Orthodox world as a title intended to emphasize the union of the two natures. But the term "God-bearer" is also used for saints in the Orthodox church, such as the "God-bearing Fathers," meaning those who lived Christ-like lives.

　　Cyril, the patriarch of Alexandria, condemned Nestorius' works byissuing twelve anathemas against him. Nestorius responded in kind. Thetwo men were harsh individuals and fierce antagonists. There was nochance of reconciliation. Emperor Theodosius II called a council atEphesus to settle the question. Working quickly, Cyril and his alliesdeposed Nestorius before his Syrian supporters could reach the councilsite. Rome backed Cyril's move and Nestorius was stripped of hisposition and exiled. Theologians who study Nestorius' writings today saythat his opinions were misrepresented and probably were notheretical.

　　Nestorius verbally and in writing refused to accept the title Theotokos (God-bearer) for Mary, the mother of Jesus. In doing so, the rest of the church felt he he was proclaiming his refusal to accept the two natures of Christ. He was embittered by the refusal of the "other side" to agree with his teaching.

　　It has been pointed out many times that there was competition -- sometimes fierce -- between Alexandria and Constantinople. Alexandria wanted a Patriarch who would understand the needs of the African Church and listen to her theologians. They were very unhappy with Nestorius.

　　

The Third Ecumenical Council at Ephesus

The Third Ecumenical Council opened on this day, the 22nd of June in 431 in the city of Ephesus in Asia Minor. It was called to resolve a dogmatic controversy that had divided the church into two main camps. Theodore of Mopsuestia, supported by Nestorius, Archbishop of Constantinople, held to what has become known as the Nestorian heresy. The opposite camp was represented by Cyril, Archbishop of Alexandria, the pope, and emperor Theodosius the Younger. Theodosius, who called the Council, believed that the strength of his empire depended upon true worship of God without the intermingling of falsehood. Two hundred fathers attended.

　　The Council opened under Cyril, a thoroughly unsympathetic figure, and a master of political intrigue. He had the agreement of Pope Celestine (who was deceased by the time the council began). Cyril was no believer in fair play. He opened the proceedings before Nestorius and his supporters arrived. For this and other actions, historians criticize Cyril of high-handedness; and of serving as both accuser and judge. But Cyril seems to have truly believed Nestorius was teaching heresy. In response he adopted a position of his own which was close to the monophysite heresy.

　　Recommended

　　9 Ways the Bible Defines True Manliness

　　A careful reading of Nestorius has led some scholars to say he was no heretic. Certainly he set out to ensure that the manhood of Christ was not lost in his deity, and eventually, grudgingly allowed the term "Theotokos" to be used as long as it was understood Mary did not thereby become a deity. Whatever the faults of Cyril's approach, he and his camp believed that Nestorianism attacked a basic dogma of the Church -- the very nature of Christ himself. They reacted fiercely, in the strongest way they knew how.

　　Nestorius' followers did not go down without a fight. In regionscontrolled by Persia they formed their own church. At the beginning, itwas a strong body which evangelized as far East as China. Nestorianchurches appeared in Arabia, India, Tibet, Malabar, Turkostan andCyprus. Many exist to this day, especially in Iraq, although the levelof spirituality is often low. Some units reunited with the RomanCatholic church around the sixteenth century.

　　In part because of the Nestorian controversy, the church created aformula to describe Christ's person at the Council of Chalcedon in 433.The assembled bishops declared Christ was two natures in one person."We all with one voice confess our Lord Jesus Christ one and thesame Son, at once complete in manhood, truly God and truly man,consisting of a reasonable soul and body; of one substance with theFather as regards his Godhead, of one substance with us as regards hismanhood, like us in all things, apart from sin..."

　　(excerpts from Painful Council Met at Ephesus, also by Dan Graves)