Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
A subtle threat to freedom
A subtle threat to freedom
Mar 19, 2025 12:23 AM

Conventional understanding may tend to gloss over the distinction between the concepts munity or society and of state or government. Many in the popular media often use the munity, society, state, and government interchangeably. mon usage of these terms introduces a fallacy with potentially dire consequences. Communal or social obligations are those that all people have mon. This does not mean that every social obligation is, or should be, enforceable by the state or government. While honest debate may ensue about exactly what constitutes munal or social obligation, before that debate can begin in earnest, a distinction must be made between society and the state. Failing to recognize this distinction introduces the specter of a totalitarianistic outlook. Of course, this outlook may not be fully developed or implemented as totalitarianistic at this particular moment, but a confusion of terms can sufficiently lay a philosophical foundation arable for totalitarianism. Said another way, blurring the meanings of the munity or society together with those of state or government establishes the philosophical footings upon which a totalitarian regime may gradually be erected.

munal, social response or reality is represented and defined by cooperation that people have with one another. This cooperation is based on shared mores, values, and customs. It is never coercive. The defining element of a social relationship is this shared, non-coercive cooperation. Robert Nisbitt, a sociologist, makes this distinction in a slightly different way. Nisbitt indicates that a distinction is to be drawn between authority and power. Both authority and power are forms of constraint. But Nisbitt notes that power is a form of constraint based on something external to the person being constrained. That is to say that power is coercive. Authority is a form of constraint that causes a person to be restricted in action or decision based not on something external, but rather on something internal to the person being constrained.

A simple illustration demonstrates this difference. A man wakes up on a beautiful Saturday morning, takes out his golf clubs, and dresses for his outing. His wife looks at him without saying a word. Her look is enough for the man to e concerned that he has done something terribly wrong, but he is not sure exactly what it is. So he asks, “What’s the matter, Honey?” She replies, “Did you forget that today was my sister’s wedding?” No more words are needed. The man meekly switches his shorts and collared short-sleeve shirt for his suit and tie. What caused the man to discontinue his golfing plans? It would not seem to be coercion, but instead the mutual submission that a husband and a wife have to each other. The man and his wife are about the same project. He has a mutual allegiance with her. The presence of this basic mutuality is the difference between authority and power. Sometimes authority, especially moral authority, can motivate people to act far more sacrificially or heroically than any act of power or legislation could ever plish. Thus, it is imperative to munity and society, which are institutions of authority, from state and government, which are institutions of power. Power, not authority, corrupts absolutely, and power exercised continually without authority eventually develops into the totalitarian nightmare.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Christian Women in India Lack Inheritance Rights. Could Hindu Nationalists Help?
  In February, the northern Indian state of Uttarakhand passed a Uniform Civil Code (UCC), which aims to implement a common set of rules governing crucial aspects of life, including marriage, divorce, inheritance, and adoption.   This code would supplant existing personal laws that religious groups in India currently ascribe to. Personal laws cover family-related matters such as marriage, divorce, child custody,...
Will Chicago Stand by Its Principles?
  The University of Chicago, from which I received my graduate degrees, has long constituted America’s model of a temple of learning, dedicated to freedom of inquiry, unconstrained either by political considerations or narrow financial ones. Under its legendary president Robert Maynard Hutchins, the school abolished its top-tier football team, based on Hutchins’s belief that high-powered sports had no connection to...
Running Through Rebellion
  Matthew 6:22-23, “The eye is the lamp of the body. So if your eye is healthy, your whole body will be full of light, but if your eye is bad, your whole body will be full of darkness. If then the light in you is darkness, how great is the darkness.”   Looking back on those years of running through rebellion,...
5 Marriage Builders You Don’t Want to Ignore
  5 Marriage Builders You Don’t Want to Ignore   By Jennifer Waddle   Therefore encourage one another and build each other up, just as in fact you are doing.”- 1 Thessalonians 5:11   Strong marriages don’t just happen; they are built over time. Just as our faith is steadily built upon a solid foundation, so our marriages are built brick-by-faithful-brick. From the moment...
‘The Chosen’ Breaks Record for Most
  The film was familiar but the language was new for Come and See CEO Stan Jantz.   As he sat in a theater in Warsaw, he looked around the room and saw people laughing and crying in the same places he had laughed and cried when he watched The Chosen, the popular streaming series that tells the story of Jesus through...
Died: KODA, the Ghanaian Gospel Star Who Sang Hits Rebuking Pastors
  Kofi Owusu Dua-Anto, a Ghanaian gospel musician who challenged church leaders with his catchy songs, died last month age 45. Known professionally as KODA, the artist passed away suddenly on April 21 after a yet-undisclosed short illness.   KODA won awards for his vocal and musical finesse and production skills, but he used the platform his music offered him to speak...
The Replication Conundrum
  Until quite recently—I cannot put an exact date on it—I assumed that everything published in scientific journals was, if not true, at least not deliberately untrue. Scientists might make mistakes, but they did not cheat, plagiarise, falsify, or make up their results. For many years as I opened a medical journal, the possibility simply that it contained fraud did not...
Christian Billionaire Goes on Trial for Major Wall Street Fraud
  Bill Hwang brought a book by Dietrich Bonhoeffer to court to read during jury selection.   And during opening arguments on Monday, his Christian connections from New York packed out a courtroom to support him.   He had given his investment firm a Christian name, held Wall Street Bible readings, and distributed millions to evangelical charities.   But federal prosecutors at Hwangs highly...
Died: Nguyen Quang Trung, Mennonite Who Led Church Through Dark Days in Vietnam
  Nguyen Quang Trung spent 30 years trying to get the Mennonite church recognized and registered by the government of Vietnam so that believers could meet and worship legally. When he finally succeeded, he celebrated the triumph with the words of the apostle Paul: If we live, we live for the Lord; and if we die, we die for the Lord....
Nanny State Screen Rules?
  InThe Anxious Generation, psychologist Jonathan Haidt has written what is, to a certain extent, a useful and important book reviewed favorably at Law Liberty. Numerous adolescent and teen mental-health metrics in the United States have markedly deteriorated in the last 15 years or so. Haidt identifies a twofold cause, which he terms the “Great Rewiring.” In his telling, smartphone proliferation...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved